汉书 · 志 · 刑法志

汉 · 班固

夫fū人rén宵xiāo天tiān地dì之zhī貌mào,怀huái五wǔ常cháng之zhī性xìng,聪cōng明míng精jīng粹cuì,有yǒu生shēng之zhī最zuì灵líng者zhě也yě。爪zhǎo牙yá不bù足zú以yǐ供gōng耆qí欲yù,趋qū走zǒu不bù足zú以yǐ避bì利lì害hài,无wú毛máo羽yǔ以yǐ御yù寒hán暑shǔ,必bì将jiāng役yì物wù以yǐ为wéi养yǎng,用yòng仁rén智zhì而ér不bù恃shì力lì,此cǐ其qí所suǒ以yǐ为wéi贵guì也yě。故gù不bù仁rén爱ài则zé不bù能néng群qún,不bù能néng群qún则zé不bù胜shèng物wù,不bù胜shèng物wù则zé养yǎng不bù足zú。群qún而ér不bù足zú,争zhēng心xīn将jiāng作zuò,上shàng圣shèng卓zhuó然rán先xiān行háng敬jìng让ràng博bó爱ài之zhī德dé者zhě,众zhòng心xīn说shuō而ér从cóng之zhī。从cóng之zhī成chéng群qún,是shì为wéi君jūn矣yǐ;归guī而ér往wǎng之zhī,是shì为wéi王wáng矣yǐ。《洪hóng范fàn》曰yuē:“天tiān子zǐ作zuò民mín父fù母mǔ,为wéi天tiān下xià王wáng。”圣shèng人rén取qǔ类lèi以yǐ正zhèng名míng,而ér谓wèi群qún为wéi父fù母mǔ,明míng仁rén、爱ài、德dé、让ràng,王wáng道dào之zhī本běn也yě。爱ài待dài敬jìng而ér不bù败bài,德dé须xū威wēi而ér久立lì,故gù制zhì礼lǐ以yǐ崇chóng敬jìng,作zuò刑xíng以yǐ明míng威wēi也yě。圣shèng人rén既jì躬gōng明míng哲zhé之zhī性xìng,必bì通tōng天tiān地dì之zhī心xīn,制zhì礼lǐ作zuò教jiào,立lì法fǎ设shè刑xíng,动dòng缘yuán民mín情qíng,而ér则zé天tiān象xiàng地dì。故gù曰yuē:先xiān王wáng立lì礼lǐ,“则zé天tiān之zhī明míng,因yīn地dì之zhī性xìng”也yě。刑xíng罚fá威wēi狱yù,以yǐ类lèi天tiān之zhī震zhèn曜yào杀shā戮lù也yě;温wēn慈cí惠huì和hé,以yǐ效xiào天tiān之zhī生shēng殖zhí长cháng育yù也yě。《书shū》云yún“天tiān秩zhì有yǒu礼lǐ”,“天tiān讨tǎo有yǒu罪zuì”。故gù圣shèng人rén因yīn天tiān秩zhì而ér制zhì五wǔ礼lǐ,因yīn天tiān讨tǎo而ér作zuò五wǔ刑xíng。大dà刑xíng用yòng甲jiǎ兵bīng,其qí次cì用yòng斧fǔ钺yuè;中zhōng刑xíng用yòng刀dāo锯jù,其qí次cì用yòng钻zuān凿záo;薄báo刑xíng用yòng鞭biān扑pū。大dà者zhě陈chén诸zhū原yuán野yě,小xiǎo者zhě致zhì之zhī市shì朝zhāo,其qí所suǒ繇yáo来lái者zhě上shàng矣yǐ。

自zì黄huáng帝dì有yǒu涿zhuō鹿lù之zhī战zhàn以yǐ定dìng火huǒ灾zāi,颛zhuān顼xū有yǒu共gòng工gōng之zhī陈chén以yǐ定dìng水shuǐ害hài。唐táng、虞yú之zhī际jì,至zhì治zhì之zhī极jí,犹yóu流共gòng工gōng,放fàng讠yán雚guàn兜dōu,窜cuàn三sān苗miáo,殛jí鲧gǔn,然rán后hòu天tiān下xià服fú。夏xià有yǒu甘gān扈hù之zhī誓shì,殷yīn、周zhōu以yǐ兵bīng定dìng天tiān下xià矣yǐ。天tiān下xià既jì定dìng,戢jí臧zāng干gān戈gē,教jiào以yǐ文wén德dé,而ér犹yóu立lì司sī马mǎ之zhī官guān,设shè六liù军jūn之zhī众zhòng,因yīn井jǐng田tián而ér制zhì军jūn赋fù。地dì方fāng一yī里lǐ为wéi井jǐng,井jǐng十shí为wéi通tōng,通tōng十shí为wéi成chéng,成chéng方fāng十shí里lǐ;成chéng十shí为wéi终zhōng,终zhōng十shí为wéi同tóng,同tóng方fāng百bǎi里lǐ;同tóng十shí为wéi封fēng,封fēng十shí为wéi畿jī,畿jī方fāng千qiān里lǐ。有yǒu税shuì有yǒu赋fù。税shuì以yǐ足zú食shí,赋fù以yǐ足zú兵bīng。故gù四sì井jǐng为wéi邑yì,四sì邑yì为wéi丘。丘,十shí六liù井jǐng也yě,有yǒu戎róng马mǎ一yī匹pǐ,牛niú三sān头tóu。四sì丘为wéi甸diàn。甸diàn,六liù十shí四sì井jǐng也yě,有yǒu戎róng马mǎ四sì匹pǐ,兵bīng车chē一yī乘chéng,牛niú十shí二èr头tóu,甲jiǎ士shì三sān人rén,卒zú七qī十shí二èr人rén,干gān戈gē备bèi具jù,是shì谓wèi乘chéng马mǎ之zhī法fǎ。一yī同tóng百bǎi里lǐ,提tí封fēng万wàn井jǐng,除chú山shān川chuān沈shěn斥chì,城chéng池chí邑yì居jū,园yuán囿yòu术shù路lù,三sān千qiān六liù百bǎi井jǐng,定dìng出chū赋fù六liù千qiān四sì百bǎi井jǐng,戎róng马mǎ四sì百bǎi匹pǐ,兵bīng车chē百bǎi乘chéng,此cǐ卿qīng大dà夫fū采cǎi地dì之zhī大dà者zhě也yě,是shì谓wèi百bǎi乘chéng之zhī家jiā。一yī封fēng三sān百bǎi一yī十shí六liù里lǐ,提tí封fēng十shí万wàn井jǐng,定dìng出chū赋fù六liù万wàn四sì千qiān井jǐng,戎róng马mǎ四sì千qiān匹pǐ,兵bīng车chē千qiān乘chéng,此cǐ诸zhū侯hóu之zhī大dà者zhě也yě,是shì谓wèi千qiān乘chéng之zhī国guó。天tiān子zǐ畿jī方fāng千qiān里lǐ,提tí封fēng百bǎi万wàn井jǐng,定dìng出chū赋fù六liù十shí四sì万wàn井jǐng,戎róng马mǎ四sì万wàn匹pǐ,兵bīng车chē万wàn乘chéng,故gù称chēng万wàn乘chéng之zhī主zhǔ。戎róng马mǎ、车chē徒tú、干gān戈gē素sù具jù,春chūn振zhèn旅以yǐ搜sōu,夏xià拔bá舍shě以yǐ苗miáo,秋qiū治zhì兵bīng以yǐ狝xiǎn,冬dōng大dà阅yuè以yǐ狩shòu,皆jiē于yú农nóng隙xì以yǐ讲jiǎng事shì焉yān。五wǔ国guó为wéi属shǔ,属shǔ有yǒu长cháng;十shí国guó为wéi连lián,连lián有yǒu帅shuài;三sān十shí国guó为wéi卒zú,卒zú有yǒu正zhèng;二èr百bǎi一yī十shí四sì为wéi州zhōu,州zhōu有yǒu牧mù。连lián师shī比bǐ年nián简jiǎn车chē,卒zú正zhèng三sān年nián简jiǎn徒tú,群qún牧mù五wǔ载zǎi大dà简jiǎn车chē、徒tú,此cǐ先xiān王wáng为wéi国guó立lì武wǔ足zú兵bīng之zhī大dà略也yě。

周zhōu道dào衰shuāi,法fǎ度dù堕duò,至zhì齐qí桓huán公gōng任rèn用yòng管guǎn仲zhòng,而ér国guó富fù民mín安ān。公gōng问wèn行háng伯bó用yòng师shī之zhī道dào,管guǎn仲zhòng曰yuē:“公gōng欲yù定dìng卒zú伍wǔ,修甲jiǎ兵bīng,大dà国guó亦yì将jiāng修之zhī,而ér小xiǎo国guó设shè备bèi,则zé难nán以yǐ速sù得dé志zhì矣yǐ。”于yú是shì乃nǎi作zuò内nèi政zhèng而ér寓yù军jūn令líng焉yān,故gù卒zú伍wǔ定dìng虖hū里lǐ,而ér军jūn政zhèng成chéng虖hū郊jiāo。连lián其qí什shí伍wǔ,居jū处chǔ同tóng乐lè,死sǐ生shēng同tóng忧yōu,祸huò福fú共gòng之zhī,故gù夜yè战zhàn则zé其qí声shēng相xiāng闻wén,昼zhòu战zhàn则zé其qí日rì相xiāng见jiàn,缓huǎn急jí足zú以yǐ相xiāng死sǐ。其qí教jiào已yǐ成chéng,外wài攘rǎng夷yí狄dí,内nèi尊zūn天tiān子zǐ,以yǐ安ān诸zhū夏xià。齐qí桓huán既jì没méi,晋jìn文wén接jiē之zhī,亦yì先xiān定dìng其qí民mín,作zuò被bèi庐lú之zhī法fǎ,总zǒng帅shuài诸zhū侯hóu,迭dié为wéi盟méng主zhǔ。然rán其qí礼lǐ已yǐ颇pō僭jiàn差chà,又yòu随suí时shí苟gǒu合hé以yǐ求欲yù速sù之zhī功gōng,故gù不bù能néng充chōng王wáng制zhì。二èr伯bó之zhī后hòu,浸jìn以yǐ陵líng夷yí,至zhì鲁lǔ成chéng公gōng作zuò丘甲jiǎ,哀āi公gōng用yòng田tián赋fù,搜sōu、狩shòu、治zhì兵bīng、大dà阅yuè之zhī事shì皆jiē失shī其qí正zhèng。《春chūn秋qiū》书shū而ér讥jī之zhī,以yǐ存cún王wáng道dào。于yú是shì师shī旅亟jí动dòng,百bǎi姓xìng罢bà敝bì,无wú伏fú节jié死sǐ难nán之zhī谊yì。孔kǒng子zǐ伤shāng焉yān,曰yuē:“以yǐ不bù教jiào民mín战zhàn,是shì谓wèi弃qì之zhī。”故gù称chēng子zǐ路lù曰yuē:“由yóu也yě,千qiān乘chéng之zhī国guó,可kě使shǐ治zhì其qí赋fù也yě。”而ér子zǐ路lù亦yì曰yuē:“千qiān乘chéng之zhī国guó,摄shè虖hū大dà国guó之zhī间jiān,加jiā之zhī以yǐ师shī旅,因yīn之zhī以yǐ饥jī馑jǐn,由yóu也yě为wéi之zhī,比bǐ及jí三sān年nián,可kě使shǐ有yǒu勇yǒng,且qiě知zhī方fāng也yě。”治zhì其qí赋fù兵bīng教jiào以yǐ礼lǐ谊yì之zhī谓wèi也yě。

春chūn秋qiū之zhī后hòu,灭miè弱ruò吞tūn小xiǎo,并bìng为wéi战zhàn国guó,稍shāo增zēng讲jiǎng武wǔ之zhī礼lǐ,以yǐ为wéi戏xì乐lè,用yòng相xiāng夸kuā视shì。而ér秦qín更gēng名míng角jiǎo抵dǐ,先xiān王wáng之zhī礼lǐ没méi于yú淫yín乐lè中zhōng矣yǐ。雄xióng桀jié之zhī士shì因yīn势shì辅fǔ时shí,作zuò为wéi权quán诈zhà以yǐ相xiāng倾qīng覆fù,吴wú有yǒu孙sūn武wǔ,齐qí有yǒu孙sūn膑bìn,魏wèi有yǒu吴wú起qǐ,秦qín有yǒu商shāng鞅yāng,皆jiē擒qín敌dí立lì胜shèng,垂chuí著zhù篇piān籍jí。当dāng此cǐ之zhī时shí,合hé纵zòng连lián衡héng,转zhuǎn相xiāng攻gōng伐fá,代dài为wéi雌cí雄xióng。齐qí愍mǐn以yǐ技jì击jī强qiáng,魏wèi惠huì以yǐ武wǔ卒zú奋fèn,秦qín昭zhāo以yǐ锐ruì士shì胜shèng。世shì方fāng争zhēng于yú功gōng利lì,而ér驰chí说shuō者zhě以yǐ孙sūn、吴wú为wéi宗zōng。时shí唯wéi孙sūn卿qīng明míng于yú王wáng道dào,而ér非fēi之zhī曰yuē:“彼bǐ孙sūn、吴wú者zhě,上shàng势shì利lì而ér贵guì变biàn诈zhà;施shī于yú暴bào乱luàn昏hūn嫚màn之zhī国guó,君jūn臣chén有yǒu间jiān,上shàng下xià离lí心xīn,政zhèng谋móu不bù良liáng,故gù可kě变biàn而ér诈zhà也yě。夫fū仁rén人rén在zài上shàng,为wéi下xià所suǒ卬yǎng,犹yóu子zǐ弟dì之zhī卫wèi父fù兄xiōng,若ruò手shǒu足zú之zhī扞hàn头tóu目mù,何hé可kě当dāng也yě?邻lín国guó望wàng我wǒ,欢huān若ruò亲qīn戚qī,芬fēn若ruò椒jiāo兰lán,顾gù视shì其qí上shàng,犹yóu焚fén灼zhuó仇chóu雠chóu。人rén情qíng岂qǐ肯kěn为wéi其qí所suǒ恶è而ér攻gōng其qí所suǒ好hǎo哉zāi?故gù以yǐ桀jié攻gōng桀jié,犹yóu有yǒu巧qiǎo拙zhuō;以yǐ桀jié诈zhà尧yáo,若ruò卵luǎn投tóu石shí,夫fū何hé幸xìng之zhī有yǒu!《诗shī》曰yuē:‘武wǔ王wáng载zǎi旆pèi,有yǒu虔qián秉bǐng钺yuè,如rú火huǒ烈liè烈liè,则zé莫mò我wǒ敢gǎn遏è。’言yán以yǐ仁rén谊yì绥suí民mín者zhě,无wú敌dí于yú天tiān下xià也yě。若ruò齐qí之zhī技jì击jī,得dé一yī首shǒu则zé受shòu赐cì金jīn。事shì小xiǎo敌dí脆cuì,则zé偷tōu可kě用yòng也yě;事shì巨jù敌dí坚jiān,则zé焕huàn然rán离lí矣yǐ。是shì亡wáng国guó之zhī兵bīng也yě。魏wèi氏shì武wǔ卒zú,衣yī三sān属shǔ之zhī甲jiǎ,操cāo十shí二èr石shí之zhī弩nǔ,负fù矢shǐ五wǔ十shí个gè,置zhì戈gē其qí上shàng,冠guān胄zhòu带dài剑jiàn,嬴yíng三sān日rì之zhī粮liáng,日rì中zhōng而ér趋qū百bǎi里lǐ,中zhōng试shì则zé复fù其qí户hù,利lì其qí田tián宅zhái。如rú此cǐ,则zé其qí地dì虽suī广guǎng,其qí税shuì必bì寡guǎ,其qí气qì力lì数shù年nián而ér衰shuāi。是shì危wēi国guó之zhī兵bīng也yě。秦qín人rén,其qí生shēng民mín也yě狭xiá厄è,其qí使shǐ民mín也yě酷kù烈liè。劫jié之zhī以yǐ势shì,隐yǐn之zhī以yǐ厄è,狃之zhī以yǐ赏shǎng庆qìng,道dào之zhī以yǐ刑xíng罚fá,使shǐ其qí民mín所suǒ以yǐ要yào利lì于yú上shàng者zhě,非fēi战zhàn无wú由yóu也yě。功gōng赏shǎng相xiāng长cháng,五wǔ甲jiǎ首shǒu而ér隶lì五wǔ家jiā,是shì最zuì为wéi有yǒu数shù,故gù能néng四sì世shì有yǒu胜shèng于yú天tiān下xià。然rán皆jiē干gān赏shǎng蹈dǎo利lì之zhī兵bīng,庸yōng徒tú鬻yù卖mài之zhī道dào耳ěr,未wèi有yǒu安ān制zhì矜jīn节jié之zhī理lǐ也yě。故gù虽suī地dì广guǎng兵bīng强qiáng,鳃sāi鳃sāi常cháng恐kǒng天tiān下xià之zhī一yī合hé而ér共gòng轧yà己jǐ也yě。至zhì乎hū齐qí桓huán、晋jìn文wén之zhī兵bīng,可kě谓wèi入rù其qí域yù而ér有yǒu节jié制zhì矣yǐ。然rán犹yóu未wèi本běn仁rén义yì之zhī统tǒng也yě。故gù齐qí之zhī技jì击jī不bù可kě以yǐ遇yù魏wèi之zhī武wǔ卒zú,魏wèi之zhī武wǔ卒zú不bù可kě以yǐ直zhí秦qín之zhī锐ruì士shì,秦qín之zhī锐ruì士shì不bù可kě以yǐ当dāng桓huán、文wén之zhī节jié制zhì,桓huán、文wén之zhī节jié制zhì不bù可kě以yǐ敌dí汤tāng、武wǔ之zhī仁rén义yì。”

故gù曰yuē:“善shàn师shī者zhě不bù陈chén,善shàn陈chén者zhě不bù战zhàn,善shàn战zhàn者zhě不bù败bài,善shàn败bài者zhě不bù亡wáng。”若ruò夫fū舜shùn修百bǎi僚liáo,咎jiù繇yáo作zuò士shì,命mìng以yǐ“蛮mán夷yí猾huá夏xià,寇kòu贼zéi奸jiān轨guǐ”,而ér刑xíng无wú所suǒ用yòng,所suǒ谓wèi善shàn师shī不bù陈chén者zhě也yě。汤tāng、武wǔ征zhēng伐fá,陈chén师shī誓shì众zhòng,而ér放fàng擒qín桀jié、纣zhòu,所suǒ谓wèi善shàn陈chén不bù战zhàn者zhě也yě。齐qí桓huán南nán服fú强qiáng楚chǔ,使shǐ贡gòng周zhōu室shì,北běi伐fá山shān戎róng,为wéi燕yàn开kāi路lù,存cún亡wáng继jì绝jué,功gōng为wéi伯bó首shǒu,所suǒ谓wèi善shàn战zhàn不bù败bài者zhě也yě。楚chǔ昭zhāo王wáng遭zāo阖hé庐lú之zhī祸huò,国guó灭miè出chū亡wáng,父fù老lǎo送sòng之zhī。王wáng曰yuē:“父fù老lǎo反fǎn矣yǐ!何hé患huàn无wú君jūn?”父fù老lǎo曰yuē:“有yǒu君jūn如rú是shì其qí贤xián也yě!”相xiāng与yǔ从cóng之zhī。或huò奔bēn走zǒu赴fù秦qín,号hào哭kū请qǐng救jiù,秦qín人rén为wéi之zhī出chū兵bīng。二èr国guó并bìng力lì,遂suì走zǒu吴wú师shī,昭zhāo王wáng返fǎn国guó,所suǒ谓wèi善shàn败bài不bù亡wáng者zhě也yě。若ruò秦qín因yīn四sì世shì之zhī胜shèng,据jù河hé山shān之zhī阻zǔ,任rèn用yòng白bái起qǐ、王wáng剪jiǎn豺chái狼láng之zhī徒tú,奋fèn其qí爪zhǎo牙yá,禽qín猎liè六liù国guó,以yǐ并bìng天tiān下xià。穷qióng武wǔ极jí诈zhà,士shì民mín不bù附fù,卒zú隶lì之zhī徒tú,还huán为wéi敌dí仇chóu,CA76起qǐ云yún合hé,果guǒ共gòng轧yà之zhī。斯sī为wéi下xià矣yǐ。凡fán兵bīng,所suǒ以yǐ存cún亡wáng继jì绝jué,救jiù乱luàn除chú害hài也yě。故gù伊yī、吕之zhī将jiāng,子zǐ孙sūn有yǒu国guó,与yǔ商shāng、周zhōu并bìng。至zhì于yú末mò世shì,苟gǒu任rèn诈zhà力lì,以yǐ快kuài贪tān残cán,急jí城chéng杀shā人rén盈yíng城chéng,争zhēng地dì杀shā人rén满mǎn野yě。孙sūn、吴wú、商shāng、白bái之zhī徒tú,皆jiē身shēn诛zhū戮lù于yú前qián,而ér国guó灭miè亡wáng于yú后hòu。报bào应yīng之zhī势shì,各gè以yǐ类lèi至zhì,其qí道dào然rán矣yǐ。

汉hàn兴xīng,高gāo祖zǔ躬gōng神shén武wǔ之zhī材cái,行háng宽kuān仁rén之zhī厚hòu,总zǒng揽lǎn英yīng雄xióng,以yǐ诛zhū秦qín、项xiàng。任rèn萧xiāo、曹cáo之zhī文wén,用yòng良liáng、平píng之zhī谋móu,骋chěng陆lù、郦lì之zhī辩biàn,明míng叔shū孙sūn通tōng之zhī仪yí,文wén武wǔ相xiāng配pèi,大dà略举jǔ焉yān。天tiān下xià既jì定dìng,踵zhǒng秦qín而ér置zhì材cái官guān于yú郡jùn国guó,京jīng师shī有yǒu南nán、北běi军jūn之zhī屯tún。至zhì武wǔ帝dì平píng百bǎi粤yuè,内nèi增zēng七qī校xiào,外wài有yǒu楼lóu船chuán,皆jiē岁suì时shí讲jiǎng肄yì,修武wǔ备bèi云yún。至zhì元yuán帝dì时shí,以yǐ贡gòng禹yǔ议yì,始shǐ罢bà角jiǎo抵dǐ,而ér未wèi正zhèng治zhì兵bīng振zhèn旅之zhī事shì也yě。

古gǔ人rén有yǒu言yán:“天tiān生shēng五wǔ材cái,民mín并bìng用yòng之zhī,废fèi一yī不bù可kě,谁shuí能néng去qù兵bīng?”鞭biān扑pū不bù可kě弛chí于yú家jiā,刑xíng罚fá不bù可kě废fèi于yú国guó,征zhēng伐fá不bù可kě偃yǎn于yú天tiān下xià。用yòng之zhī有yǒu本běn末mò,行háng之zhī有yǒu逆nì顺shùn耳ěr。孔kǒng子zǐ曰yuē:“工gōng欲yù善shàn其qí事shì,必bì先xiān利lì其qí器qì。”文wén德dé者zhě,帝dì王wáng之zhī利lì器qì;威wēi武wǔ者zhě,文wén德dé之zhī辅fǔ助zhù也yě。夫fū文wén之zhī所suǒ加jiā者zhě深shēn,则zé武wǔ之zhī所suǒ服fú者zhě大dà;德dé之zhī所suǒ施shī者zhě博bó,则zé威wēi之zhī所suǒ制zhì者zhě广guǎng。三sān代dài之zhī盛shèng,至zhì于yú刑xíng错cuò兵bīng寝qǐn者zhě,其qí本běn末mò有yǒu序xù,帝dì王wáng之zhī极jí功gōng也yě。

昔xī周zhōu之zhī法fǎ,建jiàn三sān典diǎn以yǐ刑xíng邦bāng国guó,诘jié四sì方fāng:一yī曰yuē,刑xíng新xīn邦bāng用yòng轻qīng典diǎn;二èr曰yuē,刑xíng平píng邦bāng用yòng中zhōng典diǎn;三sān曰yuē,刑xíng乱luàn邦bāng用yòng重zhòng典diǎn。五wǔ刑xíng:墨mò罪zuì五wǔ百bǎi,劓yì罪zuì五wǔ百bǎi,宫gōng罪zuì五wǔ百bǎi,刖yuè罪zuì五wǔ百bǎi,杀shā罪zuì五wǔ百bǎi,所suǒ谓wèi刑xíng平píng邦bāng用yòng中zhōng典diǎn者zhě也yě。凡fán杀shā人rén者zhě踣bó诸zhū市shì,墨mò者zhě使shǐ守shǒu门mén,劓yì者zhě使shǐ守shǒu关guān,宫gōng者zhě使shǐ守shǒu内nèi,刖yuè者zhě使shǐ守shǒu囿yòu,完wán者zhě使shǐ守shǒu积jī。其qí奴nú,男nán子zǐ入rù于yú罪zuì隶lì,女nǚ子zǐ入rù舂chōng槁gǎo。凡fán有yǒu爵jué者zhě,与yǔ七qī十shí者zhě,与yǔ未wèiB062者zhě,皆jiē不bù为wéi奴nú。

周zhōu道dào既jì衰shuāi,穆mù王wáng眊mào荒huāng,命mìng甫fǔ侯hóu度dù时shí作zuò刑xíng,以yǐ诘jié四sì方fāng。黑hēi罚fá之zhī属shǔ千qiān,劓yì罚fá之zhī属shǔ千qiān,髌bìn罚fá之zhī属shǔ五wǔ百bǎi,宫gōng罚fá之zhī属shǔ三sān百bǎi,大dà辟bì之zhī罚fá其qí属shǔ二èr百bǎi。五wǔ刑xíng之zhī属shǔ三sān千qiān,盖gài多duō于yú平píng邦bāng中zhōng典diǎn五wǔ百bǎi章zhāng,所suǒ谓wèi刑xíng乱luàn邦bāng用yòng重zhòng典diǎn者zhě也yě。

春chūn秋qiū之zhī时shí,王wáng道dào浸jìn坏huài,教jiào化huà不bù行háng,子zǐ产chǎn相xiāng郑zhèng而ér铸zhù刑xíng书shū。晋jìn叔shū向xiàng非fēi之zhī曰yuē:“昔xī先xiān王wáng议yì事shì以yǐ制zhì,不bù为wéi刑xíng辟bì。惧jù民mín之zhī有yǒu争zhēng心xīn也yě,犹yóu不bù可kě禁jīn御yù,是shì故gù闲xián之zhī以yǐ谊yì,纠之zhī以yǐ政zhèng,行háng之zhī以yǐ礼lǐ,守shǒu之zhī以yǐ信xìn,奉fèng之zhī以yǐ仁rén;制zhì为wéi禄lù位wèi以yǐ劝quàn其qí从cóng,严yán断duàn刑xíng罚fá以yǐ威wēi其qí淫yín。惧jù其qí未wèi也yě,故gù诲huì之zhī以yǐ忠zhōng,竦sǒng之zhī以yǐ行háng,教jiào之zhī以yǐ务wù,使shǐ之zhī以yǐ和hé,临lín之zhī以yǐ敬jìng,莅lì之zhī以yǐ强qiáng,断duàn之zhī以yǐ刚gāng。犹yóu求圣shèng哲zhé之zhī上shàng,明míng察chá之zhī官guān,忠zhōng信xìn之zhī长cháng,慈cí惠huì之zhī师shī。民mín于yú是shì乎hū可kě任rèn使shǐ也yě,而ér不bù生shēng祸huò乱luàn。民mín知zhī有yǒu辟bì,则zé不bù忌jì于yú上shàng,并bìng有yǒu争zhēng心xīn,以yǐ征zhēng于yú书shū,而ér侥jiǎo幸xìng以yǐ成chéng之zhī,弗fú可kě为wéi矣yǐ。夏xià有yǒu乱luàn政zhèng而ér作zuò禹yǔ刑xíng,商shāng有yǒu乱luàn政zhèng而ér作zuò汤tāng刑xíng,周zhōu有yǒu乱luàn政zhèng而ér作zuò九刑xíng。三sān辟bì之zhī兴xīng,皆jiē叔shū世shì也yě。今jīn吾wú子zǐ相xiāng郑zhèng国guó,制zhì参cān辟bì,铸zhù刑xíng书shū,将jiāng以yǐ靖jìng民mín,不bù亦yì难nán乎hū!《诗shī》曰yuē:‘仪yí式shì刑xíng文wén王wáng之zhī德dé,日rì靖jìng四sì方fāng。’又yòu曰yuē:‘仪yí刑xíng文wén王wáng,万wàn邦bāng作zuò孚fú。’如rú是shì,何hé辟bì之zhī有yǒu?民mín知zhī争zhēng端duān矣yǐ,将jiāng弃qì礼lǐ而ér征zhēng于yú书shū。锥zhuī刀dāo之zhī末mò,将jiāng尽jìn争zhēng之zhī,乱luàn狱yù滋zī丰fēng,货huò赂lù并bìng行háng。终zhōng子zǐ之zhī世shì,郑zhèng其qí败bài虖hū!”子zǐ产chǎn报bào曰yuē:“若ruò吾wú子zǐ之zhī言yán,侨qiáo不bù材cái,不bù能néng及jí子zǐ孙sūn,吾wú以yǐ救jiù世shì也yě。”偷tōu薄báo之zhī政zhèng,自zì是shì滋zī矣yǐ。孔kǒng子zǐ伤shāng之zhī,曰yuē:“导dǎo之zhī以yǐ德dé,齐qí之zhī以yǐ礼lǐ,有yǒu耻chǐ且qiě格gé;导dǎo之zhī以yǐ政zhèng,齐qí之zhī以yǐ刑xíng,民mín免miǎn而ér无wú耻chǐ。”礼lǐ乐lè不bù兴xīng,则zé刑xíng罚fá不bù中zhōng;刑xíng罚fá不bù中zhōng,则zé民mín无wú所suǒ错cuò手shǒu足zú。”孟mèng氏shì使shǐ阳yáng肤fū为wéi士shì师shī,问wèn于yú曾zēng子zǐ,亦yì曰yuē:“上shàng失shī其qí道dào,民mín散sàn久矣yǐ。如rú得dé其qí情qíng,则zé哀āi矜jīn而ér勿wù喜xǐ。”

陵líng夷yí至zhì于yú战zhàn国guó,韩hán任rèn申shēn子zǐ,秦qín用yòng商shāng鞅yāng,连lián相xiāng坐zuò之zhī法fǎ,造zào参cān夷yí之zhī诛zhū;增zēng加jiā肉ròu刑xíng、大dà辟bì,有yǒu凿záo颠diān、抽chōu胁xié、镬huò亨hēng之zhī刑xíng。

至zhì于yú秦qín始shǐ皇huáng,兼jiān吞tūn战zhàn国guó,遂suì毁huǐ先xiān王wáng之zhī法fǎ,灭miè礼lǐ谊yì之zhī官guān,专zhuān任rèn刑xíng罚fá,躬gōng操cāo文wén墨mò,昼zhòu断duàn狱yù,夜yè理lǐ书shū,自zì程chéng决jué事shì日rì县xiàn石shí之zhī一yī。而ér奸jiān邪xié并bìng生shēng,赭zhě衣yī塞sāi路lù,囹líng圄yǔ成chéng市shì,天tiān下xià愁chóu怨yuàn,溃kuì而ér叛pàn之zhī。

汉hàn兴xīng,高gāo祖zǔ初chū入rù关guān,约yuē法fǎ三sān章zhāng曰yuē:“杀shā人rén者zhě死sǐ,伤shāng人rén及jí盗dào抵dǐ罪zuì。”蠲juān削xiāo烦fán苛kē,兆zhào民mín大dà说shuō。其qí后hòu四sì夷yí未wèi附fù,兵bīng革gé未wèi息xī,三sān章zhāng之zhī法fǎ不bù足zú以yǐ御yù奸jiān,于yú是shì相xiāng国guó萧xiāo何hé攈jùn摭zhí秦qín法fǎ,取qǔ其qí宜yí于yú时shí者zhě,作zuò律lǜ九章zhāng。

当dāng孝xiào惠huì、高gāo后hòu时shí,百bǎi姓xìng新xīn免miǎn毒dú蠚hē,人rén欲yù长cháng幼yòu养yǎng老lǎo。萧xiāo、曹cáo为wéi相xiāng,填tián以yǐ无wú为wéi,从cóng民mín之zhī欲yù而ér不bù扰rǎo乱luàn,是shì以yǐ衣yī食shí滋zī殖zhí,刑xíng罚fá用yòng稀xī。

及jí孝xiào文wén即jí位wèi,躬gōng修玄xuán默mò,劝quàn趣qù农nóng桑sāng,减jiǎn省shěng租zū赋fù。而ér将jiāng相xiāng皆jiē旧jiù功gōng臣chén,少shǎo文wén多duō质zhì,惩chéng恶è亡wáng秦qín之zhī政zhèng,论lùn议yì务wù在zài宽kuān厚hòu,耻chǐ言yán人rén之zhī过guò失shī。化huà行háng天tiān下xià,告gào讦jié之zhī俗sú易yì。吏lì安ān其qí官guān,民mín乐lè其qí业yè,畜xù积jī岁suì增zēng,户hù口kǒu浸jìn息xī。风fēng流笃dǔ厚hòu,禁jīn罔wǎng疏shū阔kuò。选xuǎn张zhāng释shì之zhī为wéi廷tíng尉wèi,罪zuì疑yí者zhě予yú民mín,是shì以yǐ刑xíng罚fá大dà省shěng,至zhì于yú断duàn狱yù四sì百bǎi,有yǒu刑xíng错cuò之zhī风fēng。

即jí位wèi十shí三sān年nián齐qí太tài仓cāng令líng淳chún于yú公gōng有yǒu罪zuì当dāng刑xíng,诏zhào狱yù逮dài系xì长cháng安ān。淳chún于yú公gōng无wú男nán,有yǒu五wǔ女nǚ,当dāng行háng会huì逮dài,骂mà其qí女nǚ曰yuē:“生shēng子zǐ不bù生shēng男nán,缓huǎn急jí非fēi有yǒu益yì!”其qí少shǎo女nǚ缇tí萦yíng,自zì伤shāng悲bēi泣qì,乃nǎi随suí其qí父fù至zhì长cháng安ān,上shàng书shū曰yuē:“妾qiè父fù为wéi吏lì,齐qí中zhōng皆jiē称chēng其qí廉lián平píng,今jīn坐zuò法fǎ当dāng刑xíng。妾qiè伤shāng夫fū死sǐ者zhě不bù可kě复fù生shēng,刑xíng者zhě不bù可kě复fù属shǔ,虽suī后hòu欲yù改gǎi过guò自zì新xīn,其qí道dào亡wáng繇yáo也yě。妾qiè愿yuàn没méi入rù为wéi官guān婢bì,以yǐ赎shú父fù刑xíng罪zuì,使shǐ得dé自zì新xīn。”书shū奏zòu天tiān子zǐ,天tiān子zǐ怜lián悲bēi其qí意yì,遂suì下xià令líng曰yuē:“制zhì诏zhào御yù史shǐ:盖gài闻wén有yǒu虞yú氏shì之zhī时shí,画huà衣yī冠guān、异yì章zhāng服fú以yǐ为wéi戮lù,而ér民mín弗fú犯fàn,何hé治zhì之zhī至zhì也yě!今jīn法fǎ有yǒu肉ròu刑xíng三sān,而ér奸jiān不bù止zhǐ,其qí咎jiù安ān在zài?非fēi乃nǎi朕zhèn德dé之zhī薄báo而ér教jiào不bù明míng与yǔ?吾wú甚shèn自zì愧kuì。故gù夫fū训xùn道dào不bù纯chún而ér愚yú民mín陷xiàn焉yān,《诗shī》曰yuē:‘恺kǎi弟dì君jūn子zǐ,民mín之zhī父fù母mǔ。’今jīn人rén有yǒu过guò,教jiào未wèi施shī而ér刑xíng已yǐ加jiā焉yān,或huò欲yù改gǎi行háng为wéi善shàn,而ér道dào亡wáng繇yáo至zhì,朕zhèn甚shèn怜lián之zhī。夫fū刑xíng至zhì断duàn支zhī休xiū,刻kè肌jī肤fū,终zhōng身shēn不bù息xī,何hé其qí刑xíng之zhī痛tòng而ér不bù德dé也yě!岂qǐ为wéi民mín父fù母mǔ之zhī意yì哉zāi!其qí除chú肉ròu刑xíng,有yǒu以yǐ易yì之zhī;及jí令líng罪zuì人rén各gè以yǐ轻qīng重zhòng,不bù亡wáng逃táo,有yǒu年nián而ér免miǎn。具jù为wéi令líng。”

丞chéng相xiāng张zhāng仓cāng、御yù史shǐ大dà夫fū冯féng敬jìng奏zòu言yán:“肉ròu刑xíng所suǒ以yǐ禁jīn奸jiān,所suǒ由yóu来lái者zhě久矣yǐ。陛bì下xià下xià明míng诏zhào,怜lián万wàn民mín之zhī一yī有yǒu过guò被bèi刑xíng者zhě终zhōng身shēn不bù息xī,及jí罪zuì人rén欲yù改gǎi行háng为wéi善shàn而ér道dào亡wáng繇yáo至zhì,于yú盛shèng德dé,臣chén等děng所suǒ不bù及jí也yě。臣chén谨jǐn议yì请qǐng定dìng律lǜ曰yuē:诸zhū当dāng完wán者zhě,完wán为wéi城chéng旦dàn舂chōng;当dāng黥qíng者zhě,髡kūn钳qián为wéi城chéng旦dàn舂chōng;当dāng劓yì者zhě,笞chī三sān百bǎi;当dāng斩zhǎn左zuǒ止zhǐ者zhě,笞chī五wǔ百bǎi;当dāng斩zhǎn右yòu止zhǐ,及jí杀shā人rén先xiān自zì告gào,及jí吏lì坐zuò受shòu赇枉wǎng法fǎ,守shǒu县xiàn官guān财cái物wù而ér即jí盗dào之zhī,已yǐ论lùn命mìng复fù有yǒu笞chī罪zuì者zhě,皆jiē弃qì市shì。罪zuì人rén狱yù已yǐ决jué,完wán为wéi城chéng旦dàn舂chōng,满mǎn三sān岁suì为wéi鬼guǐ薪xīn、白bái粲càn。鬼guǐ薪xīn、白bái粲càn一yī岁suì,为wéi隶lì臣chén妾qiè。隶lì臣chén妾qiè一yī岁suì,免miǎn为wéi庶shù人rén。隶lì臣chén妾qiè满mǎn二èr岁suì,为wéi司sī寇kòu。司sī寇kòu一yī岁suì,及jí作zuò如rú司sī寇kòu二èr岁suì,皆jiē免miǎn为wéi庶shù人rén。其qí亡wáng逃táo及jí有yǒu罪zuì耐nài以yǐ上shàng,不bù用yòng此cǐ令líng。前qián令líng之zhī刑xíng城chéng旦dàn舂chōng岁suì而ér非fēi禁jīn锢gù者zhě,完wán为wéi城chéng旦dàn舂chōng岁suì数shù以yǐ免miǎn。臣chén昧mèi死sǐ请qǐng。”制zhì曰yuē:“可kě。”是shì后hòu,外wài有yǒu轻qīng刑xíng之zhī名míng,内nèi实shí杀shā人rén。斩zhǎn右yòu止zhǐ者zhě又yòu当dāng死sǐ。斩zhǎn左zuǒ止zhǐ者zhě笞chī五wǔ百bǎi,当dāng劓yì者zhě笞chī三sān百bǎi,率shuài多duō死sǐ。

景jǐng帝dì元yuán年nián,下xià诏zhào曰yuē:“加jiā笞chī与yǔ重zhòng罪zuì无wú异yì,幸xìng而ér不bù死sǐ,不bù可kě为wéi人rén。其qí定dìng律lǜ:笞chī五wǔ百bǎi曰yuē三sān百bǎi,笞chī三sān百bǎi曰yuē二èr百bǎi。”狱yù尚shàng不bù全quán。至zhì中zhōng六liù年nián,又yòu下xià诏zhào曰yuē:“加jiā笞chī者zhě,或huò至zhì死sǐ而ér笞chī未wèi毕bì,朕zhèn甚shèn怜lián之zhī。其qí减jiǎn笞chī三sān百bǎi曰yuē二èr百bǎi,笞chī二èr百bǎi曰yuē一yī百bǎi。”又yòu曰yuē:“笞chī者zhě,所suǒ以yǐ教jiào之zhī也yě,其qí定dìng棰chuí令líng。”丞chéng相xiāng刘舍shě、御yù史shǐ大dà夫fū卫wèi绾wǎn请qǐng:“笞chī者zhě,棰chuí长cháng五wǔ尺chǐ,其qí本běn大dà一yī寸cùn,其qí竹zhú也yě,末mò薄báo半bàn寸cùn,皆jiē平píng其qí节jié。当dāng笞chī者zhě,笞chī臀tún。毋wú得dé更gēng人rén,毕bì一yī罪zuì乃nǎi更gēng人rén。”自zì是shì笞chī者zhě得dé全quán,然rán酷kù吏lì犹yóu以yǐ为wéi威wēi。死sǐ刑xíng既jì重zhòng,而ér生shēng刑xíng又yòu轻qīng,民mín易yì犯fàn之zhī。

及jí至zhì孝xiào武wǔ即jí位wèi,外wài事shì四sì夷yí之zhī功gōng,内nèi盛shèng耳ěr目mù之zhī好hǎo,征zhēng发fā烦fán数shù,百bǎi姓xìng贫pín耗hào,穷qióng民mín犯fàn法fǎ,酷kù吏lì击jī断duàn,奸jiān轨guǐ不bù胜shèng。于yú是shì招zhāo进jìn张zhāng汤tāng、赵zhào禹yǔ之zhī属shǔ,条tiáo定dìng法fǎ令líng,作zuò见jiàn知zhī故gù纵zòng、监jiān临lín部bù主zhǔ之zhī法fǎ,缓huǎn深shēn故gù之zhī罪zuì,急jí纵zòng出chū之zhī诛zhū。其qí后hòu奸jiān猾huá巧qiǎo法fǎ,转zhuǎn相xiāng比bǐ况kuàng,禁jīn罔wǎng浸jìn密mì。律lǜ、令líng凡fán三sān百bǎi五wǔ十shí九章zhāng,大dà辟bì四sì百bǎi九条tiáo,千qiān八bā百bǎi八bā十shí二èr事shì,死sǐ罪zuì决jué事shì比bǐ万wàn三sān千qiān四sì百bǎi七qī十shí二èr事shì。文wén书shū盈yíng于yú几jī阁gé,典diǎn者zhě不bù能néng遍biàn睹dǔ。是shì以yǐ郡jùn国guó承chéng用yòng者zhě驳bó,或huò罪zuì同tóng而ér论lùn异yì。奸jiān吏lì因yīn缘yuán为wéi市shì,所suǒ欲yù活huó则zé傅fù生shēng议yì,所suǒ欲yù陷xiàn则zé予yú死sǐ比bǐ,议yì者zhě咸xián冤yuān伤shāng之zhī。

宣xuān帝dì自zì在zài闾阎yán而ér知zhī其qí若ruò此cǐ。及jí即jí尊zūn位wèi,廷tíng史shǐ路lù温wēn舒shū上shàng疏shū,言yán秦qín有yǒu十shí失shī,其qí一yī尚shàng存cún,治zhì狱yù之zhī吏lì是shì也yě。语yǔ在zài《温wēn舒shū传chuán》。上shàng深shēn愍mǐn焉yān,乃nǎi下xià诏zhào曰yuē:“间jiān者zhě吏lì用yòng法fǎ,巧qiǎo文wén浸jìn深shēn,是shì朕zhèn之zhī不bù德dé也yě。夫fū决jué狱yù不bù当dāng,使shǐ有yǒu罪zuì兴xīng邪xié,不bù辜gū蒙mēng戮lù,父fù子zǐ悲bēi恨hèn,朕zhèn甚shèn伤shāng之zhī。今jīn遣qiǎn廷tíng史shǐ与yǔ郡jùn鞠jū狱yù,任rèn轻qīng禄lù薄báo,其qí为wéi置zhì廷tíng平píng,秩zhì六liù百bǎi石shí,员yuán四sì人rén。其qí务wù平píng之zhī,以yǐ称chēng朕zhèn意yì。”于yú是shì选xuǎn于yú定dìng国guó为wéi廷tíng尉wèi,求明míng察chá宽kuān恕shù黄huáng霸bà等děng以yǐ为wéi廷tíng平píng,季jì秋qiū后hòu请qǐng谳yàn。时shí上shàng常cháng幸xìng宣xuān室shì,斋zhāi居jū而ér决jué事shì,狱yù刑xíng号hào为wéi平píng矣yǐ。时shí涿zhuō郡jùn太tài守shǒu郑zhèng昌chāng上shàng疏shū言yán:“圣shèng王wáng置zhì谏jiàn争zhēng之zhī臣chén者zhě,非fēi以yǐ崇chóng德dé,防fáng逸yì豫yù之zhī生shēng也yě;立lì法fǎ明míng刑xíng者zhě,非fēi以yǐ为wéi治zhì,救jiù衰shuāi乱luàn之zhī起qǐ也yě。今jīn明míng主zhǔ躬gōng垂chuí明míng听tīng,虽suī不bù置zhì廷tíng平píng,狱yù将jiāng自zì正zhèng;若ruò开kāi后hòu嗣sì,不bù若ruò删shān定dìng律lǜ令líng。律lǜ令líng一yī定dìng,愚yú民mín知zhī所suǒ避bì,奸jiān吏lì无wú所suǒ弄nòng矣yǐ。今jīn不bù正zhèng其qí本běn,而ér置zhì廷tíng平píng以yǐ理lǐ其qí末mò也yě,政zhèng衰shuāi听tīng怠dài,则zé廷tíng平píng将jiāng招zhāo权quán而ér为wéi乱luàn首shǒu矣yǐ。”宣xuān帝dì未wèi及jí修正zhèng。

至zhì元yuán席xí初chū立lì,乃nǎi下xià诏zhào曰yuē:“夫fū法fǎ令líng者zhě,所suǒ以yǐ抑yì暴bào扶fú弱ruò,欲yù其qí难nán犯fàn而ér易yì避bì也yě。今jīn律lǜ、令líng烦fán多duō而ér不bù约yuē,自zì典diǎn文wén者zhě不bù能néng分fēn明míng,而ér欲yù罗luó元yuán元yuán之zhī不bù逮dài,斯sī岂qǐ刑xíng中zhōng之zhī意yì哉zāi!其qí议yì律lǜ、令líng可kě蠲juān除chú轻qīng减jiǎn者zhě,条tiáo奏zòu,唯wéi在zài便biàn安ān万wàn姓xìng而ér已yǐ。”

至zhì成chéng帝dì河hé平píng中zhōng,复fù下xià诏zhào曰yuē:“《甫fǔ刑xíng》云yún‘五wǔ刑xíng之zhī属shǔ三sān千qiān,大dà辟bì之zhī罚fá其qí属shǔ二èr百bǎi’,今jīn大dà辟bì之zhī刑xíng千qiān有yǒu余yú条tiáo,律lǜ、令líng烦fán多duō,百bǎi有yǒu余yú万wàn言yán,奇qí请qǐng它tā比bǐ,日rì以yǐ益yì滋zī,自zì明míng习xí者zhě不bù知zhī所suǒ由yóu,欲yù以yǐ晓xiǎo喻yù众zhòng庶shù,不bù亦yì难nán乎hū!于yú以yǐ罗luó元yuán元yuán之zhī民mín,夭yāo绝jué亡wáng辜gū,岂qǐ不bù哀āi哉zāi!其qí与yǔ中zhōng二èr千qiān石shí、二èr千qiān石shí、博bó士shì及jí明míng习xí律lǜ、令líng者zhě议yì减jiǎn死sǐ刑xíng及jí可kě蠲juān除chú约yuē省shěng者zhě,令líng较jiào然rán易yì知zhī,条tiáo奏zòu。《书shū》不bù云yún乎hū?‘惟wéi刑xíng之zhī恤xù哉zāi!’其qí审shěn核hé之zhī,务wù准zhǔn古gǔ法fǎ,朕zhèn将jiāng尽jìn心xīn览lǎn焉yān。”有yǒu司sī无wú仲zhòng山shān父fù将jiāng明míng之zhī材cái,不bù能néng因yīn时shí广guǎng宣xuān主zhǔ恩ēn,建jiàn立lì明míng制zhì。为wéi一yī代dài之zhī法fǎ,而ér徒tú钩gōu摭zhí微wēi细xì,毛máo举jǔ数shù事shì,以yǐ塞sāi诏zhào而ér已yǐ。是shì以yǐ大dà议yì不bù立lì,遂suì以yǐ至zhì今jīn。议yì者zhě或huò曰yuē,法fǎ难nán数shù变biàn,此cǐ庸yōng人rén不bù达dá,疑yí塞sāi治zhì道dào,圣shèng智zhì之zhī所suǒ常cháng患huàn者zhě也yě。故gù略举jǔ汉hàn兴xīng以yǐ来lái,法fǎ令líng稍shāo定dìng而ér合hé古gǔ便biàn今jīn者zhě。

汉hàn兴xīng之zhī初chū,虽suī有yǒu约yuē法fǎ三sān章zhāng,网wǎng漏lòu吞tūn舟zhōu之zhī鱼yú。然rán其qí大dà辟bì,尚shàng有yǒu夷yí三sān族zú之zhī令líng。令líng曰yuē:“当dāng三sān族zú者zhě,皆jiē先xiān黥qíng,劓yì,斩zhǎn左zuǒ右yòu止zhǐ,笞chī杀shā之zhī,枭xiāo其qí首shǒu,菹zū其qí骨gǔ肉ròu于yú市shì。其qí诽fěi谤bàng詈lì诅zǔ者zhě,又yòu先xiān断duàn舌shé。”故gù谓wèi之zhī具jù五wǔ刑xíng。彭péng越yuè、韩hán信xìn之zhī属shǔ皆jiē受shòu此cǐ诛zhū。

至zhì高gāo后hòu元yuán年nián,乃nǎi除chú三sān族zú罪zuì、袄ǎo言yán令líng。

孝xiào文wén二èr年nián,又yòu诏zhào丞chéng相xiāng、太tài尉wèi、御yù史shǐ:“法fǎ者zhě,治zhì之zhī正zhèng,所suǒ以yǐ禁jīn暴bào而ér卫wèi善shàn人rén也yě。今jīn犯fàn法fǎ者zhě已yǐ论lùn,而ér使shǐ无wú罪zuì之zhī父fù、母mǔ、妻qī、子zǐ、同tóng产chǎn坐zuò之zhī及jí收shōu,朕zhèn甚shèn弗fú取qǔ。其qí议yì。”左zuǒ、右yòu丞chéng相xiāng周zhōu勃bó、陈chén平píng奏zòu言yán:“父fù、母mǔ、妻qī、子zǐ、同tóng产chǎn相xiāng坐zuò及jí收shōu,所suǒ以yǐ累léi其qí心xīn,使shǐ重zhòng犯fàn法fǎ也yě。收shōu之zhī之zhī道dào,所suǒ由yóu来lái久矣yǐ。臣chén之zhī愚yú计jì,以yǐ为wéi如rú其qí故gù便biàn。”文wén帝dì复fù曰yuē:“朕zhèn闻wén之zhī,法fǎ正zhèng则zé民mín悫què,罪zuì当dāng则zé民mín从cóng。且qiě夫fū牧mù民mín而ér道dào之zhī以yǐ善shàn者zhě,吏lì也yě;既jì不bù能néng道dào,又yòu以yǐ不bù正zhèng之zhī法fǎ罪zuì之zhī,是shì法fǎ反fǎn害hài于yú民mín,为wéi暴bào者zhě也yě。朕zhèn夫fū见jiàn其qí便biàn,宜yí熟shú计jì之zhī。”平píng、勃bó乃nǎi曰yuē:“陛bì下xià幸xìng加jiā大dà惠huì于yú天tiān下xià,使shǐ有yǒu罪zuì不bù收shōu,无wú罪zuì不bù相xiāng坐zuò,甚shèn盛shèng德dé,臣chén等děng所suǒ不bù及jí也yě。臣chén等děng谨jǐn奉fèng诏zhào,尽jìn除chú收shōu律lǜ、相xiāng坐zuò法fǎ。”其qí后hòu,新xīn垣yuán平píng谋móu为wéi逆nì,复fù行háng三sān族zú之zhī诛zhū。由yóu是shì言yán之zhī,风fēng俗sú移yí易yì,人rén性xìng相xiāng近jìn而ér习xí相xiāng远yuǎn,信xìn矣yǐ。夫fū以yǐ孝xiào文wén之zhī仁rén,平píng、勃bó之zhī知zhī,犹yóu有yǒu过guò刑xíng谬miù论lùn如rú此cǐ甚shèn也yě,而ér况kuàng庸yōng材cái溺nì于yú末mò流者zhě乎hū?

《周zhōu官guān》有yǒu五wǔ听tīng、八bā议yì、三sān刺cì、三sān宥yòu、三sān赦shè之zhī法fǎ。五wǔ听tīng:一yī曰yuē辞cí听tīng,二èr曰yuē色sè听tīng,三sān曰yuē气qì听tīng,四sì曰yuē耳ěr听tīng,五wǔ曰yuē目mù听tīng。八bā议yì:一yī曰yuē议yì亲qīn,二èr曰yuē议yì故gù,三sān曰yuē议yì贤xián,四sì曰yuē议yì能néng,五wǔ曰yuē议yì功gōng,六liù曰yuē议yì贵guì,七qī曰yuē议yì勤qín,八bā曰yuē议yì宾bīn。三sān刺cì:一yī曰yuē讯xùn群qún臣chén,二èr曰yuē讯xùn群qún吏lì,三sān曰yuē讯xùn万wàn民mín。三sān宥yòu:一yī曰yuē弗fú识shí,二èr曰yuē过guò失shī,三sān曰yuē遗yí忘wàng。三sān赦shè:一yī曰yuē幼yòu弱ruò,二èr曰yuē老lǎo眊mào,三sān曰yuē蠢chǔn愚yú。凡fán囚,“上shàng罪zuì梏gùBF25而ér桎zhì,中zhōng罪zuì梏gù桎zhì,下xià罪zuì梏gù;王wáng之zhī同tóng族zúBF25,有yǒu爵jué者zhě桎zhì,以yǐ待dài弊bì。”高gāo皇huáng帝dì七qī年nián,制zhì诏zhào御yù史shǐ:“狱yù之zhī疑yí者zhě,吏lì或huò不bù敢gǎn决jué,有yǒu罪zuì者zhě久而ér不bù论lùn,无wú罪zuì者zhě久系xì不bù决jué。自zì今jīn以yǐ来lái,县xiàn道dào官guān狱yù疑yí者zhě,各gè谳yàn所suǒ属shǔ二èr千qiān石shí官guān,二èr千qiān石shí官guān以yǐ其qí罪zuì名míng当dāng报bào。所suǒ不bù能néng决jué者zhě,皆jiē移yí廷tíng尉wèi,廷tíng尉wèi亦yì当dāng报bào之zhī。廷tíng尉wèi所suǒ不bù能néng决jué,谨jǐn具jù为wéi奏zòu,傅fù所suǒ当dāng比bǐ律lǜ、令líng以yǐ闻wén。”上shàng恩ēn如rú此cǐ,吏lì犹yóu不bù能néng奉fèng宣xuān。故gù孝xiào景jǐng中zhōng五wǔ年nián复fù下xià诏zhào曰yuē:“诸zhū狱yù疑yí,虽suī文wén致zhì于yú法fǎ而ér于yú人rén心xīn不bù厌yàn者zhě,辄zhé谳yàn之zhī。”其qí后hòu狱yù吏lì复fù避bì微wēi文wén,遂suì其qí愚yú心xīn。至zhì后hòu元yuán年nián,又yòu下xià诏zhào曰yuē:“狱yù,重zhòng事shì也yě。人rén有yǒu愚yú智zhì,官guān有yǒu上shàng下xià。狱yù疑yí者zhě谳yàn,有yǒu令líng谳yàn者zhě已yǐ报bào谳yàn而ér后hòu不bù当dāng,谳yàn者zhě不bù为wéi失shī。”自zì此cǐ之zhī后hòu,狱yù刑xíng益yì详xiáng,近jìn于yú五wǔ听tīng三sān宥yòu之zhī意yì。三sān年nián复fù下xià诏zhào曰yuē:“高gāo年nián老lǎo长cháng,人rén所suǒ尊zūn敬jìng也yě;鳏guān、寡guǎ不bù属shǔ逮dài者zhě,人rén所suǒ哀āi怜lián也yě。其qí著zhù令líng:年nián八bā十shí以yǐ上shàng,八bā岁suì以yǐ下xià,及jí孕yùn者zhě未wèi乳rǔ,师shī、朱zhū儒rú当dāng鞠jū系xì者zhě,颂sòng系xì之zhī。”至zhì孝xiào宣xuān元yuán康kāng四sì年nián,又yòu下xià诏zhào曰yuē:“朕zhèn念niàn夫fū耆qí老lǎo之zhī人rén,发fā齿chǐ堕duò落là,血xiě气qì既jì衰shuāi,亦yì无wú逆nì乱luàn之zhī心xīn,今jīn或huò罗luó于yú文wén法fǎ,执zhí于yú囹líng圄yǔ,不bù得dé终zhōng其qí年nián命mìng,朕zhèn甚shèn怜lián之zhī。自zì今jīn以yǐ来lái,诸zhū年nián八bā十shí非fēi诬wū告gào、杀shā伤shāng人rén,它tā皆jiē勿wù坐zuò。”至zhì成chéng帝dì鸿hóng嘉jiā元yuán年nián,定dìng令líng:“年nián未wèi满mǎn七qī岁suì,贼zéi斗dǒu杀shā人rén及jí犯fàn殊shū死sǐ者zhě,上shàng请qǐng廷tíng尉wèi以yǐ闻wén,得dé减jiǎn死sǐ。”合hé于yú三sān赦shè幼yòu弱ruò、老lǎo眊mào之zhī人rén。此cǐ皆jiē法fǎ令líng稍shāo近jìn古gǔ而ér便biàn民mín者zhě也yě。

孔kǒng子zǐ曰yuē:“如rú有yǒu王wáng者zhě,必bì世shì而ér后hòu仁rén;善shàn人rén为wéi国guó百bǎi年nián,可kě以yǐ胜shèng残cán去qù杀shā矣yǐ。”言yán圣shèng王wáng承chéng衰shuāi拨bō乱luàn而ér起qǐ,被bèi民mín以yǐ德dé教jiào,变biàn而ér化huà之zhī,必bì世shì然rán后hòu仁rén道dào成chéng焉yān;至zhì于yú善shàn人rén,不bù入rù于yú室shì,然rán犹yóu百bǎi年nián胜shèng残cán去qù杀shā矣yǐ。此cǐ为wéi国guó者zhě之zhī程chéng式shì也yě。今jīn汉hàn道dào至zhì盛shèng,历lì世shì二èr百bǎi余yú载zǎi,考kǎo自zì昭zhāo、宣xuān、元yuán、成chéng、哀āi、平píng六liù世shì之zhī间jiān,断duàn狱yù殊shū死sǐ,率shuài岁suì千qiān余yú口kǒu而ér一yī人rén,耐nài罪zuì上shàng至zhì右yòu止zhǐ,三sān倍bèi有yǒu余yú。古gǔ人rén有yǒu言yán:“满mǎn堂táng而ér饮yǐn酒,有yǒu一yī人rén乡xiāng隅yú而ér悲bēi泣qì,则zé一yī堂táng皆jiē为wéi之zhī不bù乐lè。”王wáng者zhě之zhī于yú天tiān下xià,譬pì犹yóu一yī堂táng之zhī上shàng也yě,故gù一yī人rén不bù得dé其qí平píng,为wéi之zhī凄qī怆chuàng于yú心xīn。今jīn郡jùn、国guó被bèi刑xíng而ér死sǐ者zhě岁suì以yǐ万wàn数shù,天tiān下xià狱yù二èr千qiān余yú所suǒ,其qí冤yuān死sǐ者zhě多duō少shǎo相xiāng覆fù,狱yù不bù减jiǎn一yī人rén,此cǐ和hé气qì所suǒ以yǐ未wèi洽qià者zhě也yě。

原yuán狱yù刑xíng所suǒ以yǐ蕃fán若ruò此cǐ者zhě,礼lǐ教jiào不bù立lì,刑xíng法fǎ不bù明míng,民mín多duō贫pín穷qióng,豪háo杰jié务wù私sī,奸jiān不bù辄zhé得dé,狱yùC224不bù平píng之zhī所suǒ致zhì也yě。《书shū》云yún“伯bó夷yí降jiàng典diǎn,哲zhé民mín惟wéi刑xíng”,言yán制zhì礼lǐ以yǐ止zhǐ刑xíng,犹yóu堤dī之zhī防fáng溢yì水shuǐ也yě。今jīn堤dī防fáng凌líng迟chí,礼lǐ制zhì未wèi立lì;死sǐ刑xíng过guò制zhì,生shēng刑xíng易yì犯fàn;饥jī寒hán并bìng至zhì,穷qióng斯sī滥làn溢yì;豪háo杰jié擅shàn私sī,为wéi之zhī囊náng橐tuó,奸jiān有yǒu所suǒ隐yǐn,则zé狃而ér浸jìn广guǎng:此cǐ刑xíng之zhī所suǒ以yǐ蕃fán也yě。孔kǒng子zǐ曰yuē:“古gǔ之zhī知zhī法fǎ者zhě能néng省shěng刑xíng,本běn也yě;今jīn之zhī知zhī法fǎ者zhě不bù失shī有yǒu罪zuì,末mò矣yǐ。”又yòu曰yuē:“今jīn之zhī听tīng狱yù者zhě,求所suǒ以yǐ杀shā之zhī;古gǔ之zhī听tīng狱yù者zhě,求所suǒ以yǐ生shēng之zhī。”与yǔ其qí杀shā不bù辜gū,宁níng失shī有yǒu罪zuì。今jīn之zhī狱yù吏lì,上shàng下xià相xiāng驱qū,以yǐ刻kè为wéi明míng,深shēn者zhě获huò功gōng名míng,平píng者zhě多duō患huàn害hài。谚yàn曰yuē:“鬻yù棺guān者zhě欲yù岁suì之zhī疫yì。”非fēi憎zēng人rén欲yù杀shā之zhī,利lì在zài于yú人rén死sǐ也yě。今jīn治zhì狱yù吏lì欲yù陷xiàn害hài人rén,亦yì犹yóu此cǐ矣yǐ。凡fán此cǐ五wǔ疾jí,狱yù刑xíng所suǒ以yǐ尤yóu多duō者zhě也yě。

自zì建jiàn武wǔ、永yǒng平píng,民mín亦yì新xīn免miǎn兵bīng革gé之zhī祸huò,人rén有yǒu乐lè生shēng之zhī虑lǜ,与yǔ高gāo、惠huì之zhī间jiān同tóng,而ér政zhèng在zài抑yì强qiáng扶fú弱ruò,朝zhāo无wú威wēi福fú之zhī臣chén,邑yì无wú豪háo杰jié之zhī侠xiá。以yǐ口kǒu率shuài计jì,断duàn狱yù少shǎo于yú成chéng、哀āi之zhī间jiān什shí八bā,可kě谓wèi清qīng矣yǐ。然rán而ér未wèi能néng称chēng意yì比bǐ隆lóng于yú古gǔ者zhě,以yǐ其qí疾jí未wèi尽jìn除chú,而ér刑xíng本běn不bù正zhèng。

善shàn乎hū!孙sūn卿qīng之zhī论lùn刑xíng也yě,曰yuē:“世shì俗sú之zhī为wéi说shuō者zhě,以yǐ为wéi治zhì古gǔ者zhě无wú肉ròu刑xíng,有yǒu象xiàng刑xíng、墨mò鲸jīng之zhī属shǔ,菲fēi履赭zhě衣yī而ér不bù纯chún,是shì不bù然rán矣yǐ。以yǐ为wéi治zhì古gǔ,则zé人rén莫mò触chù罪zuì邪xié,岂qǐ独dú无wú肉ròu刑xíng哉zāi,亦yì不bù待dài象xiàng刑xíng矣yǐ。以yǐ为wéi人rén或huò触chù罪zuì矣yǐ,而ér直zhí轻qīng其qí刑xíng,是shì杀shā人rén者zhě不bù死sǐ,而ér伤shāng人rén者zhě不bù刑xíng也yě。罪zuì至zhì重zhòng而ér刑xíng至zhì轻qīng,民mín无wú所suǒ畏wèi,乱luàn莫mò大dà焉yān,凡fán制zhì刑xíng之zhī本běn,将jiāng以yǐ禁jīn暴bào恶è,且qiě惩chéng其qí未wèi也yě。杀shā人rén者zhě不bù死sǐ,伤shāng人rén者zhě不bù刑xíng,是shì惠huì暴bào而ér宽kuān恶è也yě。故gù象xiàng刑xíng非fēi生shēng于yú治zhì古gǔ,方fāng起qǐ于yú乱luàn今jīn也yě。凡fán爵jué列liè官guān职zhí,赏shǎng庆qìng刑xíng罚fá,皆jiē以yǐ类lèi相xiāng从cóng者zhě也yě。一yī物wù失shī称chēng,乱luàn之zhī端duān也yě。德dé不bù称chēng位wèi,能néng不bù称chēng官guān,赏shǎng不bù当dāng功gōng,刑xíng不bù当dāng罪zuì,不bù祥xiáng莫mò大dà焉yān。夫fū征zhēng暴bào诛zhū悖bèi,治zhì之zhī威wēi也yě。杀shā人rén者zhě死sǐ,伤shāng人rén者zhě刑xíng,是shì百bǎi王wáng之zhī所suǒ同tóng也yě,未wèi有yǒu知zhī其qí所suǒ由yóu来lái者zhě也yě。故gù治zhì则zé刑xíng重zhòng,乱luàn则zé刑xíng轻qīng,犯fàn治zhì之zhī罪zuì故gù重zhòng,犯fàn乱luàn之zhī罪zuì故gù轻qīng也yě。《书shū》云yún‘刑xíng罚fá世shì重zhòng世shì轻qīng’,此cǐ之zhī谓wèi也yě。”所suǒ谓wèi“象xiàng刑xíng惟wéi明míng”者zhě,言yán象xiàng天tiān道dào而ér作zuò刑xíng,安ān有yǒu菲fēi屦jù赭zhě衣yī者zhě哉zāi?

孙sūn卿qīng之zhī言yán既jì然rán,又yòu因yīn俗sú说shuō而ér论lùn之zhī曰yuē:“禹yǔ承chéng尧yáo、舜shùn之zhī后hòu,自zì以yǐ德dé衰shuāi而ér制zhì肉ròu刑xíng,汤tāng、武wǔ顺shùn而ér行háng之zhī者zhě,以yǐ俗sú薄báo于yú唐táng、虞yú故gù也yě。今jīn汉hàn承chéng衰shuāi周zhōu暴bào秦qín极jí敝bì之zhī流,俗sú已yǐ薄báo于yú三sān代dài,而ér行háng尧yáo、舜shùn之zhī刑xíng,是shì犹yóu以yǐ鞿jī而ér御yù駻hàn突tū,违wéi救jiù时shí之zhī宜yí矣yǐ。且qiě除chú肉ròu刑xíng者zhě,本běn欲yù以yǐ全quán民mín也yě,今jīn去qù髡kūn钳qián一yī等děng,转zhuǎn而ér入rù于yú大dà辟bì,以yǐ死sǐ罔wǎng民mín,失shī本běn惠huì矣yǐ。故gù死sǐ者zhě岁suì以yǐ万wàn数shù,刑xíng重zhòng之zhī所suǒ致zhì也yě。至zhì乎hū穿chuānF1BE之zhī盗dào,忿fèn怒nù伤shāng人rén,男nán女nǚ淫yín佚yì,吏lì为wéi奸jiān臧zāng,若ruò此cǐ之zhī恶è,髡kūn钳qián之zhī罚fá又yòu不bù足zú以yǐ惩chéng也yě。故gù刑xíng者zhě岁suì十shí万wàn数shù,民mín既jì不bù畏wèi,又yòu曾zēng不bù耻chǐ,刑xíng轻qīng之zhī所suǒ生shēng也yě。故gù俗sú之zhī能néng吏lì,公gōng以yǐ杀shā盗dào为wéi威wēi,专zhuān杀shā者zhě胜shèng任rèn,奉fèng法fǎ者zhě不bù治zhì,乱luàn名míng伤shāng制zhì,不bù可kě胜shèng条tiáo。是shì以yǐ罔wǎng密mì而ér奸jiān不bù塞sāi,刑xíng蕃fán而ér民mín愈yù嫚màn。必bì世shì而ér未wèi仁rén,百bǎi年nián而ér不bù胜shèng残cán,诚chéng以yǐ礼lǐ乐lè阙quē而ér刑xíng不bù正zhèng也yě。岂qǐ宜yí惟wéi思sī所suǒ以yǐ清qīng原yuán正zhèng本běn之zhī论lùn,删shān定dìng律lǜ、令líng,B064二èr百bǎi章zhāng,以yǐ应yīng大dà辟bì。其qí余yú罪zuì次cì,于yú古gǔ当dāng生shēng,今jīn触chù死sǐ者zhě,皆jiē可kě募mù行háng肉ròu刑xíng。及jí伤shāng人rén与yǔ盗dào,吏lì受shòu赇枉wǎng法fǎ,男nán女nǚ淫yín乱luàn,皆jiē复fù古gǔ刑xíng,为wéi三sān千qiān章zhāng。诋dǐ欺qī文wén致zhì微wēi细xì之zhī法fǎ,悉xī蠲juān除chú。如rú此cǐ,则zé刑xíng可kě畏wèi而ér禁jīn易yì避bì,吏lì不bù专zhuān杀shā,法fǎ无wú二èr门mén,轻qīng重zhòng当dāng罪zuì,民mín命mìng得dé全quán,合hé刑xíng罚fá之zhī中zhōng,殷yīn天tiān人rén之zhī和hé,顺shùn稽jī古gǔ之zhī制zhì,成chéng时shí雍yōng之zhī化huà。成chéng、康kāng刑xíng错cuò,虽suī未wèi可kě致zhì,孝xiào文wén断duàn狱yù,庶shù几jī可kě及jí。《诗shī》云yún“宜yí民mín宜yí人rén,受shòu禄lù于yú天tiān”。《书shū》曰yuē“立lì功gōng立lì事shì,可kě以yǐ永yǒng年nián”。言yán为wéi政zhèng而ér宜yí于yú民mín者zhě,功gōng成chéng事shì立lì,则zé受shòu天tiān禄lù而ér永yǒng年nián命mìng,所suǒ谓wèi“一yī人rén有yǒu庆qìng,万wàn民mín赖lài之zhī”者zhě也yě。