读《三国志》法

清 · 毛宗崗

读dú《三sān国guó志zhì》者zhě,当dāng知zhī有yǒu正zhèng统tǒng、闰rùn运yùn、僭jiàn国guó之zhī别bié。正zhèng统tǒng者zhě何hé?蜀shǔ汉hàn是shì也yě。僭jiàn国guó者zhě何hé?吴wú、魏wèi是shì也yě。闰rùn运yùn者zhě何hé?晋jìn是shì也yě。魏wèi之zhī不bù得dé为wéi正zhèng统tǒng者zhě,何hé也yě?论lùn地dì则zé以yǐ中zhōng原yuán为wéi主zhǔ,论lùn理lǐ则zé以yǐ刘氏shì为wéi主zhǔ。论lùn地dì不bù若ruò论lùn理lǐ,故gù以yǐ正zhèng统tǒng予yú魏wèi者zhě,司sī马mǎ光guāng《通tōng鉴jiàn》之zhī误wù也yě。以yǐ正zhèng统tǒng予yú蜀shǔ者zhě,紫zǐ阳yáng《纲gāng目mù》之zhī所suǒ以yǐ为wéi正zhèng也yě。《纲gāng目mù》于yú献xiàn帝dì建jiàn安ān之zhī末mò,大dà书shū「后hòu汉hàn昭zhāo烈liè皇huáng帝dì章zhāng武wǔ元yuán年nián」,而ér以yǐ吴wú、魏wèi分fēn注zhù其qí下xià。盖gài以yǐ蜀shǔ为wéi帝dì室shì之zhī胄zhòu,在zài所suǒ当dāng予yú:魏wèi为wéi篡cuàn国guó之zhī贼zéi,在zài所suǒ当dāng夺duó。是shì以yǐ前qián则zé书shū「刘备bèi起qǐ兵bīng徐xú州zhōu讨tǎo曹cáo操cāo」,后hòu则zé书shū「汉hàn丞chéng相xiāng诸zhū葛gé亮liàng出chū师shī伐fá魏wèi」,而ér大dà义yì昭zhāo然rán揭jiē于yú千qiān古gǔ矣yǐ。夫fū刘氏shì未wèi亡wáng,魏wèi未wèi混hùn一yī,魏wèi固gù不bù得dé为wéi正zhèng统tǒng;迨dài乎hū刘氏shì已yǐ亡wáng,晋jìn已yǐ混hùn一yī,而ér晋jìn亦yì不bù得dé为wéi正zhèng统tǒng者zhě。何hé也yě?曰yuē:晋jìn以yǐ臣chén弑shì君jūn,与yǔ魏wèi无wú异yì,而ér一yī传chuán之zhī后hòu,厥jué祚zuò不bù长cháng,但dàn可kě谓wèi之zhī闰rùn运yùn,而ér不bù可kě谓wèi之zhī正zhèng统tǒng也yě。至zhì于yú东dōng晋jìn偏piān安ān,以yǐ牛niú易yì马mǎ,愈yù不bù得dé以yǐ正zhèng统tǒng归guī之zhī。故gù三sān国guó之zhī并bìng吞tūn于yú晋jìn,犹yóu六liù国guó之zhī混hùn一yī于yú秦qín,五wǔ代dài之zhī混hùn一yī于yú隋suí耳ěr。秦qín不bù过guò为wéi汉hàn驱qū除chú,隋suí不bù过guò为wéi唐táng驱qū除chú。前qián之zhī正zhèng统tǒng,以yǐ汉hàn为wéi主zhǔ,而ér秦qín与yǔ魏wèi、晋jìn不bù得dé与yǔ焉yān;亦yì犹yóu后hòu之zhī正zhèng统tǒng,以yǐ唐táng宋sòng为wéi主zhǔ,而ér宋sòng、齐qí、梁liáng、陈chén、隋suí、梁liáng、唐táng、晋jìn、汉hàn、周zhōu俱jù不bù得dé与yǔ焉yān耳ěr。且qiě不bù特tè魏wèi、晋jìn不bù如rú汉hàn之zhī为wéi正zhèng,即jí唐táng、宋sòng亦yì不bù如rú汉hàn之zhī为wéi正zhèng。炀yáng帝dì无wú道dào,而ér唐táng代dài之zhī,是shì已yǐ惜xī其qí不bù能néng显xiǎn然rán如rú周zhōu之zhī代dài商shāng;而ér称chēng唐táng公gōng,加jiā九锡xī,以yǐ蹈dǎo魏wèi晋jìn之zhī陋lòu辙zhé,则zé得dé天tiān下xià之zhī正zhèng不bù如rú汉hàn也yě。若ruò夫fū宋sòng以yǐ忠zhōng厚hòu立lì国guó,又yòu多duō名míng臣chén大dà儒rú出chū乎hū其qí间jiān,故gù尚shàng论lùn者zhě以yǐ正zhèng统tǒng予yú宋sòng。然rán终zhōng宋sòng之zhī世shì,燕yàn云yún十shí六liù州zhōu未wèi入rù版bǎn图tú,其qí规guī模mó已yǐ逊xùn于yú唐táng;而ér陈chén桥qiáo兵bīng变biàn,黄huáng袍páo加jiā身shēn,取qǔ天tiān下xià于yú孤gū儿ér寡guǎ妇fù之zhī手shǒu,则zé得dé天tiān下xià之zhī正zhèng亦yì不bù如rú汉hàn也yě。唐táng、宋sòng且qiě不bù如rú汉hàn,而ér何hé论lùn魏wèi、晋jìn哉zāi?高gāo帝dì以yǐ除chú暴bào秦qín、击jī楚chǔ之zhī杀shā义yì帝dì者zhě而ér兴xīng,光guāng武wǔ以yǐ诛zhū王wáng莽mǎng而ér克kè复fù旧jiù物wù,昭zhāo烈liè以yǐ讨tǎo曹cáo操cāo而ér存cún汉hàn祀sì于yú西xī川chuān。祖zǔ宗zōng之zhī创chuàng之zhī者zhě正zhèng,而ér子zǐ孙sūn之zhī继jì之zhī者zhě亦yì正zhèng,不bù得dé但dàn以yǐ光guāng武wǔ之zhī混hùn一yī为wéi正zhèng统tǒng,而ér谓wèi昭zhāo烈liè之zhī偏piān安ān非fēi正zhèng统tǒng也yě。昭zhāo烈liè为wéi正zhèng统tǒng,而ér刘裕yù、刘知zhī远yuǎn亦yì皆jiē刘氏shì子zǐ孙sūn,其qí不bù得dé为wéi正zhèng统tǒng者zhě,何hé也yě?曰yuē:裕yù与yǔ知zhī远yuǎn之zhī为wéi汉hàn苗miáo裔yì,远yuǎn而ér无wú徵zhǐ,不bù若ruò中zhōng山shān靖jìng王wáng之zhī后hòu,近jìn而ér可kě考kǎo。又yòu二èr刘皆jiē以yǐ篡cuàn弑shì得dé国guó,故gù不bù得dé与yǔ昭zhāo烈liè并bìng也yě。后hòu唐táng李lǐ存cún勖xù之zhī不bù得dé为wéi正zhèng统tǒng者zhě,何hé也yě?曰yuē:存cún勖xù本běn非fēi李lǐ而ér赐cì姓xìng李lǐ,其qí与yǔ吕秦qín、牛niú晋jìn不bù甚shèn相xiāng远yuǎn,故gù亦yì不bù得dé与yǔ昭zhāo烈liè并bìng也yě。南nán唐táng李lǐ昪biàn之zhī亦yì不bù得dé继jì唐táng而ér为wéi正zhèng统tǒng者zhě,何hé也yě?曰yuē:世shì远yuǎn代dài遐xiá,亦yì裕yù与yǔ知zhī远yuǎn者zhě比bǐ,故gù亦yì不bù得dé与yǔ昭zhāo烈liè并bìng也yě。南nán唐táng李lǐ升shēng不bù得dé继jì唐táng而ér为wéi正zhèng统tǒng,南nán宋sòng高gāo宗zōng独dú得dé继jì宋sòng而ér为wéi正zhèng统tǒng者zhě,何hé也yě?高gāo宗zōng立lì太tài祖zǔ之zhī后hòu为wéi后hòu,以yǐ延yán宋sòng祚zuò于yú不bù绝jué,故gù正zhèng统tǒng归guī焉yān。夫fū以yǐ高gāo宗zōng之zhī杀shā岳yuè飞fēi、用yòng秦qín桧guì,全quán不bù以yǐ二èr圣shèng为wéi念niàn,作zuò史shǐ者zhě尚shàng以yǐ其qí延yán宋sòng祚zuò而ér归guī之zhī以yǐ正zhèng统tǒng,况kuàng昭zhāo烈liè之zhī君jūn臣chén同tóng心xīn、誓shì讨tǎo汉hàn贼zéi者zhě乎hū?则zé昭zhāo烈liè之zhī为wéi正zhèng统tǒng,愈yù无wú疑yí也yě。陈chén寿shòu之zhī《志zhì》未wèi及jí辨biàn此cǐ,余yú故gù折zhē衷zhōng于yú紫zǐ阳yáng《纲gāng目mù》,而ér特tè于yú演yǎn义yì中zhōng附fù正zhèng之zhī。

古gǔ史shǐ甚shèn多duō,而ér人rén独dú贪tān看kàn《三sān国guó志zhì》者zhě,以yǐ古gǔ今jīn人rén才cái之zhī聚jù,未wèi有yǒu盛shèng于yú三sān国guó者zhě也yě。观guān才cái与yǔ不bù才cái敌dí不bù奇qí,观guān才cái与yǔ才cái敌dí则zé奇qí;观guān才cái与yǔ才cái敌dí,而ér一yī才cái又yòu遇yù众zhòng才cái之zhī匹pǐ不bù奇qí,观guān才cái与yǔ才cái敌dí,而ér众zhòng才cái尤yóu让ràng一yī才cái之zhī胜shèng则zé更gēng奇qí。吾wú以yǐ为wéi《三sān国guó》有yǒu三sān奇qí,可kě称chēng三sān绝jué:诸zhū葛gé孔kǒng明míng一yī绝jué也yě,关guān云yún长cháng一yī绝jué也yě,曹cáo操cāo亦yì一yī绝jué也yě。历lì稽jī载zǎi籍jí,贤xián相xiāng林lín立lì,而ér名míng高gāo万wàn古gǔ者zhě,莫mò如rú孔kǒng明míng。其qí处chǔ而ér弹dàn琴qín抱bào膝xī,居jū然rán隐yǐn士shì风fēng流;出chū而ér羽yǔ扇shàn纶lún巾jīn,不bù改gǎi雅yǎ度dù。在zài草cǎo庐lú之zhī中zhōng,而ér识shí三sān分fēn天tiān下xià,则zé达dá乎hū天tiān时shí;承chéng顾gù命mìng之zhī重zhòng,而ér至zhì六liù出chū祁qí山shān,则zé尽jìn乎hū人rén事shì。七qī擒qín八bā阵zhèn,木mù牛niú流马mǎ,既jì已yǐ疑yí鬼guǐ疑yí神shén之zhī不bù测cè;鞠jū躬gōng尽jìn瘁cuì,志zhì决jué身shēn歼jiān,仍réng是shì为wéi臣chén为wéi子zǐ之zhī用yòng心xīn。比bǐ管guǎn乐lè则zé过guò之zhī,比bǐ伊yī吕则zé兼jiān之zhī,是shì古gǔ今jīn来lái贤xián相xiāng中zhōng第dì一yī奇qí人rén。历lì稽jī载zǎi籍jí,名míng将jiāng如rú云yún,而ér绝jué伦lún超chāo群qún者zhě,莫mò如rú云yún长cháng。青qīng史shǐ对duì青qīng灯dēng,则zé极jí其qí儒rú雅yǎ;赤chì心xīn如rú赤chì面miàn,则zé极jí其qí英yīng灵líng。秉bǐng烛zhú达dá旦dàn,人rén传chuán其qí大dà节jié;单dān刀dāo赴fù会huì,世shì服fú其qí神shén威wēi。独dú行háng千qiān里lǐ,报bào主zhǔ之zhī志zhì坚jiān;义yì释shì华huá容róng,酬chóu恩ēn之zhī谊yì重zhòng。作zuò事shì如rú青qīng天tiān白bái日rì,待dài人rén如rú霁jì月yuè光guāng风fēng。心xīn则zé赵zhào抃biàn焚fén香xiāng告gào帝dì之zhī心xīn,而ér磊lěi落là过guò之zhī;意yì则zé阮ruǎn籍jí白bái眼yǎn傲ào物wù之zhī意yì,而ér严yán正zhèng过guò之zhī:是shì古gǔ今jīn来lái名míng将jiāng中zhōng第dì一yī奇qí人rén。历lì稽jī载zǎi籍jí,奸jiān雄xióng接jiē踵zhǒng,而ér智zhì足zú以yǐ揽lǎn人rén才cái而ér欺qī天tiān下xià者zhě,莫mò如rú曹cáo操cāo。听tīng荀xún彧yù勤qín王wáng之zhī说shuō,而ér自zì比bǐ周zhōu文wén,则zé有yǒu似sì乎hū忠zhōng;黜chù袁yuán术shù僭jiàn号hào之zhī非fēi,而ér愿yuàn为wéi曹cáo侯hóu,则zé有yǒu似sì乎hū顺shùn;不bù杀shā陈chén琳lín而ér爱ài其qí才cái,则zé有yǒu似sì乎hū宽kuān;不bù追zhuī关guān公gōng以yǐ全quán其qí志zhì,则zé有yǒu似sì乎hū义yì。王wáng敦dūn不bù能néng用yòng郭guō璞pú,而ér操cāo之zhī得dé士shì过guò之zhī;桓huán温wēn不bù能néng识shí王wáng猛měng,而ér操cāo之zhī知zhī人rén过guò之zhī。李lǐ林lín甫fǔ虽suī能néng制zhì禄lù山shān,不bù如rú操cāo之zhī击jī乌wū桓huán于yú塞sāi外wài;韩hán侂tuō胄zhòu虽suī能néng贬biǎn秦qín桧guì,不bù若ruò操cāo之zhī讨tǎo董dǒng卓zhuó于yú生shēng前qián。窃qiè国guó家jiā之zhī柄bǐng而ér姑gū存cún其qí号hào,异yì于yú王wáng莽mǎng之zhī显xiǎn然rán弑shì君jūn;留改gǎi革gé之zhī事shì以yǐ俟sì其qí儿ér,胜shèng于yú刘裕yù之zhī急jí欲yù篡cuàn晋jìn:是shì古gǔ今jīn来lái奸jiān雄xióng中zhōng第dì一yī奇qí人rén。有yǒu此cǐ三sān奇qí,乃nǎi前qián后hòu史shǐ之zhī所suǒ绝jué无wú者zhě。故gù读dú遍biàn诸zhū史shǐ,而ér愈yù不bù得dé不bù喜xǐ读dú《三sān国guó志zhì》也yě。

三sān国guó之zhī有yǒu三sān绝jué,固gù已yǐ。然rán吾wú自zì三sān绝jué而ér外wài,更gēng遍biàn观guān乎hū三sān国guó之zhī前qián、三sān国guó之zhī后hòu,问wèn有yǒu运yùn筹chóu帷wéi幄wò,如rú徐xú庶shù、庞páng统tǒng者zhě乎hū?问wèn有yǒu行háng军jūn用yòng兵bīng,如rú周zhōu瑜yú、陆lù逊xùn、司sī马mǎ懿yì者zhě乎hū?问wèn有yǒu料liào人rén料liào事shì,如rú郭guō嘉jiā、程chéng昱yù、荀xún彧yù、贾gǔ诩xǔ、步bù骘zhì、虞yú翻fān、顾gù雍yōng、张zhāng昭zhāo者zhě乎hū?问wèn有yǒu武wǔ功gōng将jiāng略迈mài等děng越yuè伦lún,如rú张zhāng飞fēi、赵zhào云yún、黄huáng忠zhōng、严yán颜yán、张zhāng辽liáo、徐xú晃huǎng、徐xú盛shèng、朱zhū桓huán者zhě乎hū?问wèn有yǒu冲chōng锋fēng陷xiàn阵zhèn骁xiāo锐ruì莫mò当dāng,如rú马mǎ超chāo、马mǎ岱dài、关guān兴xīng、张zhāng苞bāo、许xǔ褚zhǔ、典diǎn韦wéi、张zhāng合hé、夏xià侯hóu惇dūn、黄huáng盖gài、周zhōu泰tài、甘gān宁níng、太tài史shǐ慈cí、丁dīng奉fèng者zhě乎hū?问wèn有yǒu两liǎng才cái相xiāng当dāng、两liǎng贤xián相xiāng遇yù,如rú姜jiāng维wéi、邓dèng艾ài之zhī智zhì勇yǒng悉xī敌dí,羊yáng祜hù、陆lù抗kàng之zhī从cóng容róng互hù镇zhèn者zhě乎hū?至zhì于yú道dào学xué则zé马mǎ融róng、郑zhèng玄xuán,文wén藻zǎo则zé蔡cài邕yōng、王wáng粲càn,颖yǐng捷jié则zé曹cáo植zhí、杨yáng修,蚤zǎo慧huì则zé诸zhū葛gé恪kè、钟zhōng会huì,应yīng对duì则zé秦qín宓mì、张zhāng松sōng,舌shé辩biàn则zé李lǐ恢huī、阚kàn泽zé,不bù辱rǔ君jūn命mìng则zé赵zhào咨zī、邓dèng芝zhī,飞fēi书shū驰chí檄xí则zé陈chén琳lín、阮ruǎn瑀yǔ,治zhì烦fán理lǐ剧jù则zé蒋jiǎng琬wǎn、董dǒng允yǔn,扬yáng誉yù蜚fēi声shēng则zé马mǎ良liáng、荀xún爽shuǎng,好hǎo古gǔ则zé杜dù预yù,博bó物wù则zé张zhāng华huá,求之zhī别bié籍jí,俱jù未wèi易yì一yī一yī见jiàn也yě。乃nǎi若ruò知zhī贤xián则zé有yǒu司sī马mǎ徽huī之zhī哲zhé,励lì操cāo则zé有yǒu管guǎn宁níng之zhī高gāo,隐yǐn居jū则zé有yǒu崔cuī州zhōu平píng、石shí广guǎng元yuán、孟mèng公gōng威wēi之zhī逸yì,忤wǔ奸jiān则zé有yǒu孔kǒng融róng之zhī正zhèng,触chù邪xié则zé有yǒu赵zhào彦yàn之zhī直zhí,斥chì恶è则zé有yǒu祢mí衡héng之zhī豪háo,骂mà贼zéi则zé有yǒu吉jí平píng之zhī壮zhuàng,殉xùn国guó则zé有yǒu董dǒng承chéng、伏fú完wán之zhī贤xián,捐juān生shēng则zé有yǒu耿gěng纪jì、韦wéi晃huǎng之zhī节jié。子zǐ死sǐ于yú父fù,则zé有yǒu刘谌chén、关guān平píng之zhī孝xiào;臣chén死sǐ于yú君jūn,则zé有yǒu诸zhū葛gé瞻zhān、诸zhū葛gé尚shàng之zhī忠zhōng;部bù曲qū死sǐ于yú主zhǔ帅shuài,则zé有yǒu赵zhào累léi、周zhōu仓cāng之zhī义yì。其qí他tā早zǎo计jì如rú田tián丰fēng,苦kǔ口kǒu如rú王wáng累léi,矢shǐ贞zhēn如rú沮jǔ授shòu,不bù屈qū如rú张zhāng任rèn,轻qīng财cái笃dǔ友yǒu如rú鲁lǔ肃sù,事shì主zhǔ不bù二èr心xīn如rú诸zhū葛gé瑾jǐn,不bù畏wèi强qiáng御yù如rú陈chén泰tài,视shì死sǐ如rú归guī如rú王wáng经jīng,独dú存cún介jiè性xìng如rú司sī马mǎ孚fú,炳bǐng炳bǐng磷lín磷lín,照zhào耀yào史shǐ册cè。殆dài举jǔ前qián之zhī丰fēng沛pèi三sān杰jié、商shāng山shān四sì皓hào、云yún台tái诸zhū将jiāng、富fù春chūn客kè星xīng,后hòu之zhī瀛yíng洲zhōu学xué士shì、麟lín阁gé功gōng臣chén、杯bēi酒节jié度dù、柴chái市shì宰zǎi相xiāng,分fēn见jiàn于yú各gè朝zhāo之zhī千qiān百bǎi年nián者zhě,奔bēn合hé辎zī凑còu于yú三sān国guó之zhī一yī时shí,岂qǐ非fēi人rén才cái一yī大dà都dū会huì哉zāi!入rù邓dèng林lín而ér选xuǎn名míng材cái,游yóu玄xuán圃pǔ而ér见jiàn积jī玉yù,收shōu不bù胜shèng收shōu,接jiē不bù暇xiá接jiē,吾wú于yú《三sān国guó》有yǒu观guān止zhǐ之zhī叹tàn矣yǐ。

《三sān国guó》一yī书shū,乃nǎi文wén章zhāng之zhī最zuì妙miào者zhě。叙xù三sān国guó,不bù自zì三sān国guó始shǐ也yě,三sān国guó必bì有yǒu所suǒ自zì始shǐ,则zé始shǐ之zhī以yǐ汉hàn帝dì。叙xù三sān国guó,不bù自zì三sān国guó终zhōng也yě,三sān国guó必bì有yǒu所suǒ言yán终zhōng,则zé终zhōng之zhī以yǐ晋jìn国guó。而ér不bù但dàn此cǐ也yě,刘备bèi以yǐ帝dì胄zhòu而ér缵zuǎn统tǒng,则zé有yǒu宗zōng室shì如rú刘表biǎo、刘璋zhāng、刘繇yáo、刘辟bì等děng以yǐ陪péi之zhī;曹cáo操cāo以yǐ强qiáng臣chén而ér专zhuān制zhì,则zé有yǒu废fèi立lì如rú董dǒng卓zhuó,乱luàn国guó如rú李lǐ傕què、郭guō汜sì以yǐ陪péi之zhī。孙sūn权quán以yǐ方fāng侯hóu而ér分fēn鼎dǐng,则zé有yǒu僭jiàn号hào如rú袁yuán术shù,称chēng雄xióng如rú袁yuán绍shào,割gē据jù如rú吕布bù、公gōng孙sūn瓒zàn、张zhāng杨yáng、张zhāng邈miǎo、张zhāng鲁lǔ、张zhāng绣xiù等děng以yǐ陪péi之zhī。刘备bèi、曹cáo操cāo,于yú第dì一yī回huí出chū名míng,而ér孙sūn权quán则zé于yú第dì七qī回huí方fāng出chū名míng。曹cáo氏shì之zhī定dìng许xǔ都dū,在zài第dì十shí一yī回huí;孙sūn氏shì之zhī定dìng江jiāng东dōng,在zài第dì十shí二èr回huí;而ér刘氏shì之zhī取qǔ西xī川chuān,则zé在zài第dì六liù十shí回huí后hòu。假jiǎ令líng今jīn人rén作zuò稗bài官guān,欲yù平píng空kōng拟nǐ一yī《三sān国guó》之zhī事shì,势shì必bì劈pī头tóu便biàn叙xù三sān人rén,三sān人rén便biàn各gè据jù一yī国guó,有yǒu能néng如rú是shì之zhī统tǒng乎hū其qí前qián、出chū乎hū其qí后hòu,多duō方fāng以yǐ盘pán旋xuán乎hū其qí左zuǒ右yòu者zhě哉zāi?古gǔ事shì所suǒ传chuán,天tiān然rán有yǒu此cǐ等děng波bō澜lán,天tiān然rán有yǒu此cǐ等děng层céng折zhē,以yǐ成chéng绝jué世shì妙miào文wén。然rán则zé读dú《三sān国guó》一yī书shū,诚chéng胜shèng读dú稗bài官guān万wàn万wàn耳ěr。

若ruò论lùn三sān国guó开kāi基jī之zhī主zhǔ,人rén尽jìn知zhī为wéi刘备bèi、孙sūn权quán、曹cáo操cāo也yě,而ér不bù知zhī其qí间jiān各gè有yǒu不bù同tóng。备bèi与yǔ操cāo皆jiē自zì我wǒ身shēn而ér创chuàng业yè,而ér孙sūn权quán则zé籍jí父fù兄xiōng之zhī力lì,其qí不bù同tóng者zhě一yī。备bèi与yǔ权quán皆jiē及jí身shēn而ér为wéi帝dì,而ér操cāo则zé不bù自zì为wéi而ér待dài之zhī于yú其qí子zǐ孙sūn,其qí不bù同tóng者zhě二èr。三sān国guó之zhī称chēng帝dì也yě,惟wéi魏wèi独dú早zǎo,而ér蜀shǔ则zé称chēng帝dì于yú曹cáo操cāo已yǐ死sǐ、曹cáo丕pī已yǐ立lì之zhī馀yú,吴wú则zé称chēng帝dì于yú刘备bèi已yǐ死sǐ、刘禅chán已yǐ立lì之zhī后hòu,其qí不bù同tóng者zhě三sān。三sān国guó之zhī相xiāng持chí也yě,吴wú为wéi蜀shǔ之zhī邻lín,魏wèi为wéi蜀shǔ之zhī雠chóu;蜀shǔ与yǔ吴wú有yǒu和hé有yǒu战zhàn,而ér蜀shǔ与yǔ魏wèi则zé有yǒu战zhàn无wú和hé;吴wú与yǔ蜀shǔ则zé和hé多duō于yú战zhàn,吴wú与yǔ魏wèi则zé战zhàn多duō于yú和hé,其qí不bù同tóng者zhě四sì。三sān国guó之zhī传chuán也yě,蜀shǔ止zhǐ二èr世shì,魏wèi则zé自zì丕pī及jí奂huàn凡fán五wǔ主zhǔ,吴wú则zé自zì权quán及jí皓hào凡fán四sì主zhǔ,其qí不bù同tóng者zhě五wǔ。三sān国guó之zhī亡wáng也yě,吴wú居jū其qí后hòu,而ér蜀shǔ先xiān之zhī,魏wèi次cì之zhī。魏wèi则zé见jiàn夺duó于yú其qí臣chén,吴wú、蜀shǔ则zé见jiàn并bìng于yú其qí敌dí,其qí不bù同tóng者zhě六liù。不bù宁níng惟wéi是shì,策cè之zhī与yǔ权quán,则zé兄xiōng终zhōng而ér弟dì及jí;丕pī之zhī与yǔ植zhí,则zé舍shě弟dì而ér立lì兄xiōng;备bèi之zhī与yǔ禅chán,则zé父fù为wéi帝dì而ér子zǐ为wéi虏lǔ;操cāo之zhī与yǔ丕pī,则zé父fù为wéi臣chén而ér子zǐ为wéi君jūn:可kě谓wèi参cān差chà错cuò落là,变biàn化huà无wú方fāng者zhě矣yǐ。今jīn之zhī不bù善shàn画huà者zhě,虽suī使shǐ绘huì两liǎng人rén,亦yì必bì彼bǐ此cǐ同tóng貌mào。今jīn之zhī不bù善shàn歌gē者zhě,即jí使shǐ唱chàng两liǎng调tiáo,亦yì必bì前qián后hòu同tóng声shēng。文wén之zhī合hé掌zhǎng,往wǎng往wǎng类lèi是shì。古gǔ人rén本běn无wú雷léi同tóng之zhī事shì,而ér今jīn人rén好hǎo为wéi雷léi同tóng之zhī文wén。则zé何hé不bù取qǔ余yú所suǒ批pī《三sān国guó志zhì》而ér读dú之zhī?

《三sān国guó》一yī书shū,总zǒng起qǐ总zǒng结jié之zhī中zhōng,又yòu有yǒu六liù起qǐ六liù结jié。其qí叙xù献xiàn帝dì,则zé以yǐ董dǒng卓zhuó废fèi立lì为wéi一yī起qǐ,以yǐ曹cáo丕pī篡cuàn夺duó为wéi一yī结jié;其qí叙xù西xī蜀shǔ,则zé以yǐ成chéng都dū称chēng帝dì为wéi一yī起qǐ,而ér以yǐ绵mián竹zhú出chū降jiàng为wéi一yī结jié;其qí叙xù刘、关guān、张zhāng三sān人rén,则zé以yǐ桃táo园yuán结jié义yì为wéi一yī起qǐ,而ér以yǐ白bái帝dì托tuō孤gū为wéi一yī结jié。其qí叙xù诸zhū葛gé亮liàng,则zé以yǐ三sān顾gù草cǎo庐lú为wéi一yī起qǐ,而ér以yǐ六liù出chū祁qí山shān为wéi一yī结jié;其qí叙xù魏wèi国guó,则zé以yǐ黄huáng初chū改gǎi元yuán为wéi一yī起qǐ,而ér以yǐ司sī马mǎ受shòu禅chán为wéi一yī结jié;其qí叙xù东dōng吴wú,则zé以yǐ孙sūn坚jiān匿nì玺xǐ为wéi一yī起qǐ,而ér以yǐ孙sūn皓hào衔xián璧bì为wéi一yī结jié。凡fán此cǐ数shù段duàn文wén字zì,联lián络luò交jiāo互hù于yú其qí间jiān,或huò此cǐ方fāng起qǐ而ér彼bǐ已yǐ结jié,或huò此cǐ未wèi结jié而ér彼bǐ又yòu起qǐ。读dú之zhī不bù见jiàn其qí断duàn续xù之zhī迹jì,而ér按àn之zhī则zé自zì有yǒu章zhāng法fǎ之zhī可kě知zhī也yě。

《三sān国guó》一yī书shū,有yǒu追zhuī本běn穷qióng源yuán之zhī妙miào。三sān国guó之zhī分fēn,由yóu于yú诸zhū镇zhèn之zhī角jiǎo立lì。诸zhū镇zhèn角jiǎo立lì,由yóu于yú董dǒng卓zhuó之zhī乱luàn国guó。董dǒng卓zhuó乱luàn国guó,由yóu于yú何hé进jìn之zhī召zhào外wài兵bīng。何hé进jìn召zhào外wài兵bīng,由yóu于yú十shí常cháng侍shì之zhī专zhuān政zhèng。故gù叙xù三sān国guó,必bì以yǐ十shí常cháng侍shì为wéi之zhī端duān也yě。然rán而ér刘备bèi之zhī初chū起qǐ,不bù即jí在zài诸zhū镇zhèn之zhī内nèi,而ér尚shàng在zài草cǎo泽zé之zhī间jiān。夫fū草cǎo泽zé之zhī所suǒ以yǐ有yǒu英yīng雄xióng聚jù义yì,而ér诸zhū镇zhèn之zhī所suǒ以yǐ缮shàn修兵bīng革gé者zhě,由yóu于yú黄huáng巾jīn之zhī作zuò乱luàn。故gù叙xù三sān国guó,又yòu必bì以yǐ黄huáng巾jīn为wéi之zhī端duān也yě。乃nǎi黄huáng巾jīn未wèi作zuò,则zé有yǒu上shàng天tiān垂chuí灾zāi异yì以yǐ警jǐng戒jiè之zhī,更gēng有yǒu忠zhōng谋móu智zhì计jì之zhī士shì直zhí言yán极jí谏jiàn以yǐ预yù料liào之zhī。使shǐ当dāng时shí为wéi之zhī君jūn者zhě,体tǐ天tiān心xīn之zhī仁rén爱ài,纳nà良liáng臣chén之zhī谠dǎng论lùn,断duàn然rán举jǔ十shí常cháng侍shì而ér迸bèng斥chì焉yān,则zé黄huáng巾jīn可kě以yǐ不bù作zuò,草cǎo泽zé英yīng雄xióng可kě以yǐ不bù起qǐ,诸zhū镇zhèn之zhī兵bīng革gé可kě以yǐ不bù修,而ér三sān国guó可kě以yǐ不bù分fēn矣yǐ。故gù叙xù三sān国guó而ér追zhuī本běn于yú桓huán、灵líng,犹yóu河hé源yuán之zhī有yǒu星xīng宿sù海hǎi云yún。

《三sān国guó》一yī书shū,有yǒu巧qiǎo收shōu幻huàn结jié之zhī妙miào。设shè令líng魏wèi而ér为wéi蜀shǔ所suǒ并bìng,此cǐ人rén心xīn之zhī所suǒ甚shèn愿yuàn也yě。设shè令líng蜀shǔ亡wáng而ér魏wèi得dé一yī统tǒng,此cǐ人rén心xīn之zhī所suǒ大dà不bù平píng也yě。乃nǎi彼bǐ苍cāng之zhī意yì,不bù从cóng人rén心xīn所suǒ甚shèn愿yuàn,而ér亦yì不bù出chū于yú人rén心xīn之zhī所suǒ大dà不bù平píng,特tè假jiǎ手shǒu于yú晋jìn以yǐ一yī之zhī,此cǐ造zào物wù者zhě之zhī幻huàn也yě。然rán天tiān既jì不bù祚zuò汉hàn,又yòu不bù予yú魏wèi,则zé何hé不bù假jiǎ手shǒu于yú吴wú,而ér必bì假jiǎ手shǒu于yú晋jìn乎hū?曰yuē:魏wèi固gù汉hàn贼zéi也yě,吴wú尝cháng害hài关guān公gōng,夺duó荆jīng州zhōu,助zhù魏wèi以yǐ攻gōng蜀shǔ,则zé亦yì汉hàn贼zéi也yě。若ruò晋jìn之zhī夺duó魏wèi,有yǒu似sì乎hū为wéi汉hàn报bào雠chóu也yě者zhě,则zé与yǔ其qí一yī之zhī以yǐ吴wú,无wú宁níng一yī之zhī以yǐ晋jìn也yě。且qiě吴wú为wéi魏wèi敌dí,而ér晋jìn为wéi魏wèi臣chén;魏wèi以yǐ臣chén弑shì君jūn,而ér晋jìn即jí如rú其qí事shì以yǐ报bào之zhī,可kě以yǐ为wéi戒jiè于yú天tiān下xià后hòu世shì,则zé使shǐ魏wèi而ér见jiàn并bìng于yú其qí敌dí,不bù若ruò使shǐ之zhī见jiàn并bìng于yú其qí臣chén之zhī为wéi快kuài也yě,是shì造zào物wù者zhě之zhī巧qiǎo也yě。幻huàn既jì出chū人rén意yì外wài,巧qiǎo复fù在zài人rén意yì中zhōng,造zào物wù者zhě可kě谓wèi善shàn于yú作zuò文wén矣yǐ。今jīn人rén下xià笔bǐ,必bì不bù能néng如rú此cǐ之zhī幻huàn、如rú此cǐ之zhī巧qiǎo,然rán则zé读dú造zào物wù自zì然rán之zhī文wén,而ér又yòu何hé必bì读dú今jīn人rén臆yì造zào之zhī文wén乎hū哉zāi!

《三sān国guó》一yī书shū,有yǒu以yǐ宾bīn衬chèn主zhǔ之zhī妙miào。如rú将jiāng叙xù桃táo园yuán兄xiōng弟dì三sān人rén,先xiān叙xù黄huáng巾jīn兄xiōng弟dì三sān人rén:桃táo园yuán其qí主zhǔ也yě,黄huáng巾jīn其qí宾bīn也yě。将jiāng叙xù中zhōng山shān靖jìng王wáng之zhī后hòu,先xiān叙xù鲁lǔ恭gōng王wáng之zhī后hòu:中zhōng山shān靖jìng王wáng其qí主zhǔ也yě,鲁lǔ恭gōng王wáng其qí宾bīn也yě。将jiāng叙xù何hé进jìn,先xiān叙xù陈chén蕃fán、窦dòu武wǔ:何hé进jìn其qí主zhǔ也yě,陈chén蕃fán、窦dòu武wǔ其qí宾bīn也yě。叙xù刘、关guān、张zhāng及jí曹cáo操cāo、孙sūn坚jiān之zhī出chū色sè,并bìng叙xù各gè镇zhèn诸zhū侯hóu之zhī无wú用yòng:刘备bèi、曹cáo操cāo、孙sūn坚jiān其qí主zhǔ也yě,各gè镇zhèn诸zhū侯hóu其qí宾bīn也yě。刘备bèi将jiāng遇yù诸zhū葛gé亮liàng,而ér先xiān遇yù司sī马mǎ徽huī、崔cuī州zhōu平píng、石shí广guǎng元yuán、孟mèng公gōng威wēi等děng诸zhū人rén:诸zhū葛gé亮liàng其qí主zhǔ也yě,司sī马mǎ徽huī诸zhū人rén其qí宾bīn也yě。诸zhū葛gé亮liàng历lì事shì两liǎng朝zhāo,乃nǎi又yòu有yǒu先xiān来lái即jí去qù之zhī徐xú庶shù、晚wǎn来lái先xiān死sǐ之zhī庞páng统tǒng:诸zhū葛gé亮liàng其qí主zhǔ也yě,而ér徐xú庶shù、庞páng统tǒng又yòu其qí宾bīn也yě。赵zhào云yún先xiān事shì公gōng孙sūn瓒zàn,黄huáng忠zhōng先xiān事shì韩hán玄xuán,马mǎ超chāo先xiān事shì张zhāng鲁lǔ,法fǎ正zhèng、严yán颜yán先xiān事shì刘璋zhāng,而ér后hòu皆jiē归guī刘备bèi:备bèi其qí主zhǔ也yě,公gōng孙sūn瓒zàn、韩hán玄xuán、张zhāng鲁lǔ、刘璋zhāng其qí宾bīn也yě。太tài史shǐ慈cí先xiān事shì刘繇yáo,后hòu归guī孙sūn策cè,甘gān宁níng先xiān事shì黄huáng祖zǔ,后hòu归guī孙sūn权quán;张zhāng辽liáo先xiān事shì吕布bù,徐xú晃huǎng先xiān事shì杨yáng奉fèng,张zhāng合hé先xiān事shì袁yuán绍shào,贾gǔ诩xǔ先xiān事shì李lǐ傕què、张zhāng绣xiù,而ér后hòu皆jiē归guī曹cáo操cāo:孙sūn、曹cáo其qí主zhǔ也yě,刘繇yáo、黄huáng祖zǔ、吕布bù、杨yáng奉fèng等děng诸zhū人rén其qí宾bīn也yě。代dài汉hàn当dāng涂tú之zhī谶chèn,本běn应yīng在zài魏wèi,而ér袁yuán公gōng路lù谬miù以yǐ自zì许xǔ:魏wèi其qí主zhǔ也yě,袁yuán公gōng路lù其qí宾bīn也yě。三sān马mǎ同tóng槽cáo之zhī梦mèng,本běn应yīng在zài司sī马mǎ氏shì,而ér曹cáo操cāo误wù以yǐ为wéi马mǎ腾téng父fù子zǐ:司sī马mǎ氏shì其qí主zhǔ也yě,马mǎ腾téng父fù子zǐ其qí宾bīn也yě。受shòu禅chán台tái之zhī说shuō,李lǐ肃sù以yǐ赚zhuàn董dǒng卓zhuó,而ér曹cáo丕pī即jí真zhēn焉yān,司sī马mǎ炎yán又yòu即jí真zhēn焉yān:曹cáo丕pī,司sī马mǎ炎yán其qí主zhǔ也yě,董dǒng卓zhuó其qí宾bīn也yě。且qiě不bù独dú人rén有yǒu宾bīn主zhǔ也yě,地dì亦yì有yǒu之zhī。献xiàn帝dì自zì洛luò阳yáng迁qiān长cháng安ān,又yòu自zì长cháng安ān迁qiān洛luò阳yáng,而ér终zhōng乃nǎi迁qiān于yú于yú许xǔ昌chāng:许xǔ昌chāng其qí主zhǔ也yě,长cháng安ān、洛luò阳yáng皆jiē宾bīn也yě。刘备bèi失shī徐xú州zhōu,而ér得dé荆jīng州zhōu:荆jīng州zhōu其qí主zhǔ也yě,徐xú州zhōu其qí宾bīn也yě。及jí得dé两liǎng川chuān,而ér复fù失shī荆jīng州zhōu:两liǎng川chuān其qí主zhǔ也yě,而ér荆jīng州zhōu又yòu其qí宾bīn也yě。孔kǒng明míng将jiāng北běi伐fá中zhōng原yuán,而ér先xiān南nán定dìng蛮mán方fāng,意yì不bù在zài蛮mán方fāng而ér在zài中zhōng原yuán:中zhōng原yuán其qí主zhǔ也yě,蛮mán方fāng其qí宾bīn也yě。抑yì不bù独dú地dì有yǒu宾bīn主zhǔ也yě,物wù亦yì有yǒu之zhī。李lǐ儒rú持chí鸩zhèn酒、短duǎn刀dāo、白bái练liàn以yǐ贻yí帝dì辩biàn:鸩zhèn酒其qí主zhǔ也yě,短duǎn刀dāo、白bái练liàn其qí宾bīn也yě。许xǔ田tián打dǎ围wéi,将jiāng叙xù曹cáo操cāo射shè鹿lù,先xiān叙xù玄xuán德dé射shè兔tù:鹿lù其qí主zhǔ也yě,兔tù其qí宾bīn也yě。赤chì壁bì鏖áo兵bīng,将jiāng叙xù孔kǒng明míng借jiè风fēng,先xiān叙xù孔kǒng明míng借jiè箭jiàn:风fēng其qí主zhǔ也yě,箭jiàn其qí宾bīn也yě。董dǒng承chéng受shòu玉yù带dài,陪péi之zhī以yǐ锦jǐn袍páo:带dài其qí主zhǔ也yě,袍páo其qí宾bīn也yě。关guān公gōng拜bài受shòu赤chì兔tù马mǎ,而ér陪péi之zhī以yǐ金jīn印yìn、红hóng袍páo诸zhū赐cì:马mǎ其qí主zhǔ也yě,金jīn印yìn等děng其qí宾bīn也yě。曹cáo操cāo掘jué地dì得dé铜tóng雀què,而ér陪péi之zhī以yǐ玉yù龙lóng、金jīn凤fèng:雀què其qí主zhǔ也yě,龙lóng、凤fèng其qí宾bīn也yě。诸zhū如rú此cǐ类lèi,不bù可kě悉xī数shù。善shàn读dú是shì书shū者zhě,可kě于yú此cǐ悟wù文wén章zhāng宾bīn主zhǔ之zhī法fǎ。

《三sān国guó》一yī书shū,有yǒu同tóng树shù异yì枝zhī、同tóng枝zhī异yì叶yè、同tóng叶yè异yì花huā、同tóng花huā异yì果guǒ之zhī妙miào。作zuò文wén者zhě以yǐ善shàn避bì为wéi能néng,又yòu以yǐ善shàn犯fàn为wéi能néng。不bù犯fàn之zhī而ér求避bì之zhī,无wú所suǒ见jiàn其qí避bì也yě;惟wéi犯fàn之zhī而ér后hòu避bì之zhī,乃nǎi见jiàn其qí能néng避bì也yě。如rú纪jì宫gōng掖yè,则zé写xiě一yī何hé太tài后hòu,又yòu写xiě一yī董dǒng太tài后hòu;写xiě一yī伏fú皇huáng后hòu,又yòu写xiě一yī曹cáo皇huáng后hòu;写xiě一yī唐táng贵guì妃fēi,又yòu写xiě一yī董dǒng贵guì人rén;写xiě甘gān、糜mí二èr夫fū人rén,又yòu写xiě一yī孙sūn夫fū人rén,又yòu写xiě一yī北běi地dì王wáng妃fēi;写xiě魏wèi之zhī甄zhēn后hòu、毛máo后hòu,又yòu写xiě一yī张zhāng后hòu:而ér其qí间jiān无wú一yī字zì相xiāng同tóng。纪jì戚qī畹wǎn,则zé何hé进jìn之zhī后hòu,写xiě一yī董dǒng承chéng,董dǒng承chéng之zhī后hòu,又yòu写xiě一yī伏fú完wán;写xiě一yī魏wèi之zhī张zhāng缉jī,又yòu写xiě一yī吴wú之zhī钱qián尚shàng:而ér其qí间jiān亦yì无wú一yī字zì相xiāng同tóng。写xiě权quán臣chén,则zé董dǒng卓zhuó之zhī后hòu,又yòu写xiě李lǐ傕què、郭guō汜sì;傕què、汜sì之zhī后hòu,又yòu写xiě曹cáo操cāo;曹cáo操cāo之zhī后hòu,又yòu写xiě一yī曹cáo丕pī;曹cáo丕pī之zhī后hòu,又yòu写xiě一yī司sī马mǎ懿yì;司sī马mǎ懿yì之zhī后hòu,又yòu并bìng写xiě一yī师shī、昭zhāo兄xiōng弟dì;师shī、昭zhāo之zhī后hòu,又yòu继jì写xiě一yī司sī马mǎ炎yán,又yòu旁páng写xiě一yī吴wú之zhī孙sūn綝lín:而ér其qí间jiān亦yì无wú一yī字zì相xiāng同tóng。其qí他tā叙xù兄xiōng弟dì之zhī事shì,则zé袁yuán谭tán与yǔ袁yuán尚shàng不bù睦mù、刘琦qí与yǔ刘琮cóng不bù睦mù,曹cáo丕pī与yǔ曹cáo植zhí亦yì不bù睦mù,而ér谭tán与yǔ尚shàng皆jiē死sǐ,琦qí与yǔ琮cóng一yī死sǐ一yī不bù死sǐ,丕pī与yǔ植zhí皆jiē不bù死sǐ,不bù大dà异yì乎hū!叙xù婚hūn姻yīn之zhī事shì,则zé如rú董dǒng卓zhuó求婚hūn于yú孙sūn坚jiān,袁yuán术shù约yuē婚hūn于yú吕布bù,曹cáo操cāo约yuē婚hūn于yú袁yuán谭tán,孙sūn权quán结jié婚hūn于yú刘备bèi、又yòu求婚hūn于yú云yún长cháng,而ér或huò绝jué而ér不bù许xǔ,或huò许xǔ而ér复fù绝jué,或huò伪wěi约yuē而ér反fǎn成chéng,或huò真zhēn约yuē而ér不bù就jiù,不bù大dà异yì乎hū?至zhì于yú王wáng允yǔn用yòng美měi人rén计jì,周zhōu瑜yú亦yì用yòng美měi人rén计jì,而ér一yī效xiào一yī不bù效xiào,则zé互hù异yì;卓zhuó、布bù相xiāng恶è,傕què、汜sì亦yì相xiāng恶è,而ér一yī靖jìng一yī不bù靖jìng,则zé互hù异yì。献xiàn帝dì有yǒu两liǎng番fān密mì诏zhào,则zé前qián隐yǐn而ér后hòu彰zhāng;马mǎ腾téng亦yì有yǒu两liǎng番fān讨tǎo贼zéi,则zé前qián彰zhāng而ér后hòu隐yǐn:此cǐ其qí不bù同tóng者zhě矣yǐ。吕布bù有yǒu两liǎng番fān弑shì父fù,而ér前qián动dòng于yú财cái,后hòu动dòng于yú色sè;前qián则zé以yǐ私sī灭miè公gōng,后hòu则zé假jiǎ公gōng济jì私sī,此cǐ又yòu其qí不bù同tóng者zhě矣yǐ。赵zhào云yún有yǒu两liǎng番fān救jiù主zhǔ,而ér前qián救jiù于yú陆lù,后hòu救jiù于yú水shuǐ;前qián则zé受shòu之zhī主zhǔ母mǔ之zhī手shǒu,后hòu则zé夺duó之zhī主zhǔ母mǔ之zhī怀huái:此cǐ又yòu其qí不bù同tóng者zhě矣yǐ。若ruò夫fū写xiě水shuǐ不bù止zhǐ一yī番fān,写xiě火huǒ亦yì不bù止zhǐ一yī番fān。曹cáo操cāo有yǒu下xià邳pī之zhī水shuǐ,又yòu有yǒu冀jì州zhōu之zhī水shuǐ;关guān公gōng有yǒu白bái河hé之zhī水shuǐ,又yòu有yǒu罾zēng口kǒu川chuān之zhī水shuǐ。吕布bù有yǒu濮pú阳yáng之zhī火huǒ,曹cáo操cāo有yǒu乌wū巢cháo之zhī火huǒ,周zhōu郎láng有yǒu赤chì壁bì之zhī火huǒ.陆lù逊xùn有yǒu猇xiāo亭tíng之zhī火huǒ,徐xú盛shèng有yǒu南nán徐xú之zhī火huǒ,武wǔ侯hóu有yǒu博bó望wàng、新xīn野yě之zhī火huǒ,又yòu有yǒu盘pán蛇shé谷gǔ、上shàng方fāng谷gǔ之zhī火huǒ:前qián后hòu曾zēng有yǒu丝sī毫háo相xiāng犯fàn否fǒu?甚shèn者zhě孟mèng获huò之zhī擒qín有yǒu七qī,祁qí山shān之zhī出chū有yǒu六liù,中zhōng原yuán之zhī伐fá有yǒu九,求其qí一yī字zì之zhī相xiāng犯fàn而ér不bù可kě得dé。妙miào哉zāi文wén乎hū!譬pì犹yóu树shù同tóng是shì树shù,枝zhī同tóng是shì枝zhī,叶yè同tóng是shì叶yè,花huā同tóng是shì花huā,而ér其qí植zhí根gēn、安ān蒂dì、吐tǔ芳fāng、结jié子zǐ,五wǔ色sè纷fēn披pī,各gè成chéng异yì采cǎi。读dú者zhě于yú此cǐ,可kě悟wù文wén章zhāng有yǒu避bì之zhī一yī法fǎ,又yòu有yǒu犯fàn之zhī一yī法fǎ也yě。

《三sān国guó》一yī书shū,有yǒu星xīng移yí斗dǒu转zhuǎn、雨yǔ覆fù风fēng翻fān之zhī妙miào。杜dù少shǎo陵líng诗shī曰yuē:「天tiān上shàng浮fú云yún如rú白bái衣yī,斯sī须xū改gǎi变biàn成chéng苍cāng狗gǒu。」此cǐ言yán世shì事shì之zhī不bù可kě测cè也yě。《三sān国guó》之zhī文wén,亦yì犹yóu是shì尔ěr。本běn是shì何hé进jìn谋móu诛zhū宦huàn官guān,却què弄nòng出chū宦huàn官guān杀shā何hé进jìn,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì吕布bù助zhù丁dīng原yuán,却què弄nòng出chū吕布bù杀shā丁dīng原yuán,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì董dǒng卓zhuó结jié吕布bù,却què弄nòng出chū吕布bù杀shā董dǒng卓zhuó,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì陈chén宫gōng释shì曹cáo操cāo,却què弄nòng出chū陈chén宫gōng欲yù杀shā曹cáo操cāo,则zé一yī变biàn;陈chén宫gōng未wèi杀shā曹cáo操cāo,反fǎn弄nòng出chū曹cáo操cāo杀shā陈chén官guān,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì王wáng允yǔn不bù赦shè傕què、汜sì,却què弄nòng出chū傕què、汜sì杀shā王wáng允yǔn,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì孙sūn坚jiān与yǔ袁yuán术shù不bù睦mù,却què弄nòng出chū袁yuán术shù致zhì书shū于yú孙sūn坚jiān,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì刘表biǎo求救jiù于yú袁yuán绍shào,却què弄nòng出chū刘表biǎo杀shā孙sūn坚jiān,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì昭zhāo烈liè从cóng袁yuán绍shào以yǐ讨tǎo董dǒng卓zhuó,却què弄nòng出chū助zhù公gōng孙sūn瓒zàn以yǐ攻gōng袁yuán绍shào,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì昭zhāo烈liè救jiù徐xú州zhōu,却què弄nòng出chū昭zhāo烈liè取qǔ徐xú州zhōu,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì吕布bù投tóu徐xú州zhōu,却què弄nòng出chū吕布bù夺duó徐xú州zhōu,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì吕布bù攻gōng昭zhāo烈liè,却què弄nòng出chū吕布bù迎yíng昭zhāo烈liè,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì吕布bù绝jué袁yuán术shù,又yòu弄nòng出chū吕布bù求袁yuán术shù,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì昭zhāo烈liè助zhù吕布bù以yǐ讨tǎo袁yuán术shù,又yòu弄nòng出chū助zhù曹cáo操cāo以yǐ杀shā吕布bù,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì昭zhāo烈liè助zhù曹cáo操cāo,又yòu弄nòng出chū昭zhāo烈liè讨tǎo曹cáo操cāo,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì昭zhāo烈liè攻gōng袁yuán绍shào,又yòu弄nòng出chū昭zhāo烈liè投tóu袁yuán绍shào,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì昭zhāo烈liè助zhù袁yuán绍shào以yǐ攻gōng曹cáo操cāo,又yòu弄nòng出chū关guān公gōng助zhù曹cáo操cāo以yǐ攻gōng袁yuán绍shào,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì关guān公gōng寻xún昭zhāo烈liè,又yòu弄nòng出chū张zhāng飞fēi欲yù杀shā关guān公gōng,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì关guān公gōng许xǔ田tián欲yù杀shā曹cáo操cāo,又yòu弄nòng出chū华huá客kè道dào放fàng曹cáo操cāo,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì曹cáo操cāo追zhuī昭zhāo烈liè,又yòu弄nòng出chū昭zhāo烈liè投tóu东dōng吴wú以yǐ破pò曹cáo操cāo,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì孙sūn权quán雠chóu刘表biǎo,又yòu弄nòng出chū鲁lǔ肃sù吊diào刘表biǎo、又yòu吊diào刘琦qí,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì孔kǒng明míng助zhù周zhōu郎láng,却què弄nòng出chū周zhōu郎láng欲yù杀shā孔kǒng明míng,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì周zhōu郎láng欲yù害hài昭zhāo烈liè,却què弄nòng出chū孙sūn权quán结jié婚hūn昭zhāo烈liè,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì用yòng孙sūn夫fū人rén牵qiān制zhì昭zhāo烈liè,却què弄nòng出chū孙sūn夫fū人rén助zhù昭zhāo烈liè,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì孔kǒng明míng气qì死sǐ周zhōu郎láng,又yòu弄nòng出chū孔kǒng明míng哭kū周zhōu郎láng,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì昭zhāo烈liè不bù受shòu刘表biǎo荆jīng州zhōu,却què弄nòng出chū昭zhāo烈liè借jiè荆jīng州zhōu,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì刘璋zhāng欲yù结jié曹cáo操cāo,却què弄nòng出chū迎yíng昭zhāo烈liè,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì刘璋zhāng迎yíng昭zhāo烈liè,却què弄nòng出chū昭zhāo烈liè夺duó刘璋zhāng,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì昭zhāo烈liè分fēn荆jīng州zhōu,又yòu弄nòng出chū吕蒙mēng袭xí荆jīng州zhōu,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì昭zhāo烈liè破pò东dōng吴wú,又yòu弄nòng出chū陆lù逊xùn败bài昭zhāo烈liè,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì孙sūn权quán求救jiù于yú曹cáo丕pī,却què弄nòng出chū曹cáo丕pī欲yù袭xí孙sūn权quán,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì昭zhāo烈liè雠chóu东dōng吴wú,又yòu弄nòng出chū孔kǒng明míng结jié好hǎo东dōng吴wú,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì刘封fēng听tīng孟mèng达dá,却què弄nòng出chū刘封fēng攻gōng孟mèng达dá,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì孟mèng达dá背bèi昭zhāo烈liè,又yòu弄nòng出chū孟mèng达dá欲yù归guī孔kǒng明míng,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì马mǎ腾téng与yǔ昭zhāo烈liè同tóng事shì,又yòu弄nòng出chū马mǎ超chāo攻gōng昭zhāo烈liè,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì马mǎ超chāo救jiù刘璋zhāng,却què弄nòng出chū马mǎ超chāo投tóu昭zhāo烈liè,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì姜jiāng维wéi敌dí孔kǒng明míng,却què弄nòng出chū姜jiāng维wéi助zhù孔kǒng明míng,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì夏xià侯hóu霸bà助zhù司sī马mǎ懿yì,却què弄nòng出chū夏xià侯hóu霸bà助zhù姜jiāng维wéi,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì钟zhōng会huì忌jì邓dèng艾ài,却què弄nòng出chū卫wèi瓘guàn杀shā邓dèng艾ài,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì姜jiāng维wéi赚zhuàn钟zhōng会huì,却què弄nòng出chū诸zhū将jiāng杀shā钟zhōng会huì,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì羊yáng祜hù和hé陆lù抗kàng,却què弄nòng出chū羊yáng祜hù请qǐng伐fá孙sūn皓hào,则zé一yī变biàn;本běn是shì羊yáng祜hù请qǐng伐fá吴wú,却què弄nòng出chū一yī杜dù预yù,又yòu弄nòng出chū一yī王wáng浚jùn,则zé一yī变biàn。论lùn其qí呼hū应yīng有yǒu法fǎ,则zé读dú前qián卷juàn定dìng知zhī其qí有yǒu后hòu卷juàn;论lùn其qí变biàn化huà无wú方fāng,则zé读dú前qián文wén更gēng不bù料liào其qí有yǒu后hòu文wén。于yú其qí可kě知zhī,见jiàn《三sān国guó》之zhī文wén之zhī精jīng;于yú其qí不bù可kě料liào,更gēng见jiàn《三sān国guó》之zhī文wén之zhī幻huàn矣yǐ。

《三sān国guó》一yī书shū,有yǒu横héng云yún断duàn岭lǐng、横héng桥qiáo锁suǒ溪xī之zhī妙miào。文wén有yǒu宜yí于yú连lián者zhě,有yǒu宜yí于yú断duàn者zhě。如rú五wǔ关guān斩zhǎn将jiāng、三sān顾gù草cǎo庐lú、七qī擒qín孟mèng获huò,此cǐ文wén之zhī妙miào于yú连lián者zhě也yě。如rú三sān气qì周zhōu瑜yú、六liù出chū祁qí山shān、九伐fá中zhōng原yuán,此cǐ文wén之zhī妙miào于yú断duàn者zhě也yě。盖gài文wén之zhī短duǎn者zhě,不bù连lián叙xù则zé不bù贯guàn串chuàn,文wén之zhī长cháng者zhě,连lián叙xù则zé惧jù其qí累léi坠zhuì,故gù必bì叙xù别bié事shì以yǐ间jiān之zhī,而ér后hòu文wén势shì乃nǎi错cuò综zōng尽jìn变biàn。后hòu世shì稗bài官guān家jiā,鲜xiān能néng及jí此cǐ。

《三sān国guó》一yī书shū,有yǒu将jiāng雪xuě见jiàn霰xiàn、将jiāng雨yǔ闻wén雷léi之zhī妙miào。将jiāng有yǒu一yī段duàn正zhèng文wén在zài后hòu,必bì先xiān有yǒu一yī段duàn闲xián文wén以yǐ为wéi之zhī引yǐn。将jiāng有yǒu一yī段duàn大dà文wén在zài后hòu,必bì先xiān有yǒu一yī段duàn小xiǎo文wén以yǐ为wéi之zhī端duān。如rú将jiāng叙xù曹cáo操cāo濮pú阳yáng之zhī火huǒ,先xiān写xiě糜mí竺zhú家jiā中zhōng之zhī火huǒ一yī段duàn闲xián文wén以yǐ启qǐ之zhī;将jiāng叙xù孔kǒng融róng求救jiù于yú昭zhāo烈liè,先xiān写xiě孔kǒng融róng通tōng刺cì于yú李lǐ弘hóng一yī段duàn闲xián文wén以yǐ启qǐ之zhī;将jiāng叙xù赤chì壁bì纵zòng火huǒ一yī段duàn大dà文wén,先xiān写xiě博bó望wàng、新xīn野yě两liǎng段duàn小xiǎo文wén以yǐ启qǐ之zhī;将jiāng叙xù六liù出chū祁qí山shān一yī段duàn大dà文wén,先xiān写xiě七qī擒qín孟mèng获huò一yī段duàn小xiǎo文wén以yǐ启qǐ之zhī是shì也yě。鲁lǔ人rén将jiāng有yǒu事shì于yú上shàng帝dì,必bì先xiān有yǒu事shì于yú頖pàn宫gōng。文wén章zhāng之zhī妙miào,正zhèng复fù类lèi是shì。

《三sān国guó》一yī书shū,有yǒu浪làng后hòu波bō纹wén、雨yǔ后hòu霢mài霢mài之zhī妙miào。凡fán文wén之zhī奇qí者zhě,文wén前qián必bì有yǒu先xiān声shēng,文wén后hòu亦yì必bì有yǒu馀yú势shì。如rú董dǒng卓zhuó之zhī后hòu,又yòu有yǒu从cóng贼zéi以yǐ继jì之zhī;黄huáng巾jīn之zhī后hòu,又yòu有yǒu馀yú党dǎng以yǐ衍yǎn之zhī;昭zhāo烈liè三sān顾gù草cǎo庐lú之zhī后hòu,又yòu有yǒu刘琦qí三sān请qǐng诸zhū葛gé一yī段duàn文wén字zì以yǐ映yìng带dài之zhī;武wǔ侯hóu出chū师shī一yī段duàn大dà文wén之zhī后hòu,又yòu有yǒu姜jiāng维wéi伐fá魏wèi一yī段duàn文wén字zì以yǐ荡dàng漾yàng之zhī是shì也yě。诸zhū如rú此cǐ类lèi,皆jiē他tā书shū中zhōng所suǒ未wèi有yǒu。

《三sān国guó》一yī书shū,有yǒu寒hán冰bīng破pò热rè、凉liáng风fēng扫sǎo尘chén之zhī妙miào。如rú关guān公gōng五wǔ关guān斩zhǎn将jiāng之zhī时shí,忽hū有yǒu镇zhèn国guó寺sì内nèi遇yù普pǔ静jìng长cháng老lǎo一yī段duàn文wén字zì;昭zhāo烈liè跃yuè马mǎ檀tán溪xī之zhī时shí,忽hū有yǒu水shuǐ镜jìng庄zhuāng上shàng遇yù司sī马mǎ先xiān生shēng一yī段duàn文wén字zì;孙sūn策cè虎hǔ踞jù江jiāng东dōng之zhī时shí,忽hū有yǒu遇yù于yú吉jí一yī段duàn文wén字zì;曹cáo操cāo进jìn爵jué魏wèi王wáng之zhī时shí,忽hū有yǒu遇yù左zuǒ慈cí一yī段duàn文wén字zì;昭zhāo烈liè三sān顾gù草cǎo庐lú之zhī时shí,忽hū有yǒu遇yù崔cuī州zhōu平píng席xí地dì闲xián谈tán一yī段duàn文wén字zì;关guān公gōng水shuǐ淹yān七qī军jūn之zhī后hòu,忽hū有yǒu玉yù泉quán山shān月yuè下xià点diǎn化huà一yī段duàn文wén字zì。至zhì于yú武wǔ侯hóu征zhēng蛮mán,而ér忽hū逢féng孟mèng节jié;陆lù逊xùn追zhuī蜀shǔ,而ér忽hū遇yù黄huáng承chéng彦yàn;张zhāng任rèn临lín敌dí,而ér忽hū间jiān紫zǐ虚xū丈zhàng人rén:昭zhāo烈liè伐fá吴wú,而ér忽hū问wèn青qīng城chéng老lǎo叟sǒu:或huò僧sēng、或huò道dào、或huò隐yǐn士shì、或huò高gāo人rén,俱jù于yú极jí喧xuān闹nào中zhōng求之zhī,真zhēn足zú令líng人rén躁zào思sī顿dùn清qīng,烦fán襟jīn尽jìn涤dí。

《三sān国guó》一yī书shū,有yǒu笙shēng箫xiāo夹jiā鼓gǔ、琴qín瑟sè间jiān钟zhōng之zhī妙miào。如rú正zhèng叙xù黄huáng巾jīn扰rǎo乱luàn,忽hū有yǒu何hé后hòu、董dǒng后hòu两liǎng宫gōng争zhēng论lùn一yī段duàn文wén字zì;正zhèng叙xù董dǒng卓zhuó纵zòng横héng,忽hū有yǒu貂diāo蝉chán凤fèng仪yí亭tíng一yī段duàn文wén字zì;正zhèng叙xù傕què、汜sì倡chàng狂kuáng,忽hū有yǒu杨yáng彪biāo夫fū人rén与yǔ郭guō汜sì之zhī妻qī来lái往wǎng一yī段duàn文wén字zì;正zhèng叙xù下xià邳pī交jiāo战zhàn,忽hū有yǒu吕布bù送sòng女nǚ、严yán氏shì恋liàn夫fū一yī段duàn文wén字zì;正zhèng叙xù冀jì州zhōu厮sī杀shā,忽hū有yǒu袁yuán谭tán失shī妻qī、曹cáo丕pī纳nà妇fù一yī段duàn文wén字zì;正zhèng叙xù荆jīng州zhōu事shì变biàn,忽hū有yǒu蔡cài夫fū人rén商shāng议yì一yī段duàn文wén字zì;正zhèng叙xù赤chì壁bì鏖áo兵bīng,忽hū有yǒu曹cáo操cāo欲yù取qǔ二èr乔qiáo一yī段duàn文wén字zì;正zhèng叙xù宛wǎn城chéng交jiāo攻gōng,忽hū有yǒu张zhāng济jì妻qī与yǔ曹cáo操cāo相xiāng遇yù一yī段duàn文wén字zì;正zhèng叙xù赵zhào云yún取qǔ桂guì阳yáng,忽hū有yǒu赵zhào范fàn寡guǎ嫂sǎo敬jìng酒一yī段duàn文wén字zì;正zhèng叙xù昭zhāo烈liè争zhēng荆jīng州zhōu,忽hū有yǒu孙sūn权quán亲qīn妹mèi洞dòng房fáng花huā烛zhú一yī段duàn文wén字zì;正zhèng叙xù孙sūn权quán战zhàn黄huáng祖zǔ,忽hū有yǒu孙sūn翊yì妻qī为wéi夫fū报bào雠chóu一yī段duàn文wén字zì;正zhèng叙xù司sī马mǎ懿yì杀shā曹cáo爽shuǎng,忽hū有yǒu辛xīn宪xiàn英yīng为wéi弟dì画huà策cè一yī段duàn文wén字zì。至zhì于yú袁yuán绍shào讨tǎo曹cáo操cāo之zhī时shí,忽hū带dài叙xù郑zhèng康kāng成chéng之zhī婢bì;曹cáo操cāo救jiù汉hàn中zhōng之zhī日rì,忽hū带dài叙xù蔡cài中zhōng郎láng之zhī女nǚ:诸zhū如rú此cǐ类lèi,不bù一yī而ér足zú。人rén但dàn知zhī《三sān国guó》之zhī文wén是shì叙xù龙lóng争zhēng虎hǔ斗dǒu之zhī事shì,而ér不bù知zhī为wéi凤fèng为wéi鸾luán、为wéi莺yīng为wéi燕yàn,篇piān中zhōng有yǒu应yīng接jiē不bù暇xiá者zhě。令líng人rén于yú干gān戈gē队duì里lǐ里lǐ,时shí见jiàn红hóng裙qún;旌jīng旗qí影yǐng中zhōng,常cháng睹dǔ粉fěn黛dài:殆dài以yǐ豪háo士shì传chuán与yǔ美měi人rén传chuán合hé为wéi一yī书shū矣yǐ。

《三sān国guó》一yī书shū,有yǒu隔gé年nián下xià种zhǒng、先xiān时shí伏fú着zhuó之zhī妙miào。善shàn圃pǔ者zhě投tóu种zhǒng于yú地dì,待dài时shí而ér发fā;善shàn奕yì者zhě下xià一yī闲xián著zhù着zhuó于yú数shù十shí著zhù之zhī前qián,而ér其qí应yīng在zài数shù十shí著zhù之zhī后hòu。文wén章zhāng叙xù事shì之zhī法fǎ,亦yì犹yóu是shì已yǐ。如rú西xī蜀shǔ刘璋zhāng乃nǎi刘焉yān之zhī子zǐ,而ér首shǒu回huí将jiāng叙xù刘备bèi,先xiān叙xù刘焉yān,早zǎo为wéi取qǔ西xī川chuān伏fú下xià一yī笔bǐ。又yòu于yú玄xuán德dé破pò黄huáng巾jīn时shí,并bìng叙xù曹cáo操cāo,带dài叙xù董dǒng卓zhuó,早zǎo为wéi董dǒng卓zhuó乱luàn国guó、曹cáo操cāo专zhuān权quán伏fú下xià一yī笔bǐ。赵zhào云yún归guī昭zhāo烈liè在zài古gǔ城chéng聚jù义yì之zhī时shí,而ér昭zhāo烈liè之zhī遇yù赵zhào云yún,早zǎo于yú磐pán河hé战zhàn公gōng孙sūn时shí伏fú下xià一yī笔bǐ。马mǎ超chāo归guī昭zhāo烈liè在zài葭jiā萌méng战zhàn张zhāng飞fēi之zhī后hòu,而ér昭zhāo烈liè之zhī与yǔ马mǎ腾téng同tóng事shì,早zǎo于yú受shòu衣yī带dài诏zhào时shí伏fú下xià一yī笔bǐ。庞páng统tǒng归guī昭zhāo烈liè在zài周zhōu郎láng既jì死sǐ之zhī后hòu,而ér童tóng子zǐ述shù庞páng统tǒng姓xìng名míng,早zǎo于yú水shuǐ镜jìng庄zhuāng前qián伏fú下xià一yī笔bǐ。武wǔ侯hóu叹tàn「谋móu事shì在zài人rén、成chéng事shì在zài天tiān」在zài上shàng方fāng谷gǔ火huǒ灭miè之zhī后hòu,而ér司sī马mǎ徽huī「未wèi遇yù其qí时shí」之zhī语yǔ,崔cuī州zhōu平píng「天tiān不bù可kě强qiáng」之zhī言yán,早zǎo于yú三sān顾gù草cǎo庐lú前qián伏fú下xià一yī笔bǐ。刘禅chán帝dì蜀shǔ四sì十shí馀yú年nián而ér终zhōng,在zài一yī百bǎi十shí回huí之zhī后hòu,而ér鹤hè鸣míng之zhī兆zhào,早zǎo于yú新xīn野yě初chū生shēng时shí伏fú下xià一yī笔bǐ。姜jiāng维wéi九伐fá中zhōng原yuán在zài一yī百bǎi五wǔ回huí之zhī后hòu,而ér武wǔ侯hóu之zhī收shōu姜jiāng维wéi,早zǎo于yú初chū出chū祁qí山shān时shí伏fú下xià一yī笔bǐ。姜jiāng维wéi与yǔ邓dèng艾ài相xiāng遇yù,在zài三sān伐fá中zhōng原yuán之zhī后hòu,姜jiāng维wéi与yǔ钟zhōng会huì相xiāng遇yù,在zài九伐fá中zhōng原yuán之zhī后hòu,而ér夏xià侯hóu霸bà述shù两liǎng人rén姓xìng名míng,早zǎo于yú未wèi伐fá中zhōng原yuán时shí伏fú下xià一yī笔bǐ。曹cáo丕pī篡cuàn汉hàn,在zài八bā十shí回huí中zhōng,而ér青qīng云yún紫zǐ云yún之zhī祥xiáng,早zǎo于yú三sān十shí三sān回huí之zhī前qián伏fú下xià一yī笔bǐ。孙sūn权quán僭jiàn号hào,在zài八bā十shí五wǔ回huí后hòu,而ér吴wú夫fū人rén梦mèng日rì之zhī兆zhào,早zǎo于yú三sān十shí八bā回huí中zhōng伏fú下xià一yī笔bǐ。司sī马mǎ篡cuàn魏wèi,在zài一yī百bǎi十shí九回huí,而ér曹cáo操cāo梦mèng马mǎ之zhī兆zhào,早zǎo于yú五wǔ十shí七qī回huí中zhōng伏fú下xià一yī笔bǐ。自zì此cǐ而ér外wài,凡fán伏fú笔bǐ之zhī处chǔ,指zhǐ不bù胜shèng屈qū。每měi见jiàn近jìn世shì稗bài官guān家jiā,一yī到dào扭捏niē不bù来lái之zhī时shí,便biàn平píng空kōng生shēng出chū一yī人rén,无wú端duān造zào出chū一yī事shì,觉jué后hòu文wén与yǔ前qián文wén隔gé断duàn,更gēng不bù相xiāng涉shè。试shì令líng读dú《三sān国guó》之zhī文wén,能néng不bù汗hàn颜yán?

《三sān国guó》一yī书shū,有yǒu添tiān丝sī补bǔ锦jǐn、移yí针zhēn匀yún绣xiù之zhī妙miào。凡fán叙xù事shì之zhī法fǎ,此cǐ篇piān所suǒ阙quē者zhě补bǔ之zhī于yú彼bǐ篇piān,上shàng卷juàn所suǒ多duō者zhě匀yún之zhī于yú下xià卷juàn。不bù但dàn使shǐ前qián文wén不bù沓tà拖tuō,而ér亦yì使shǐ后hòu文wén不bù寂jì寞mò;不bù但dàn使shǐ前qián事shì无wú遗yí漏lòu,而ér又yòu使shǐ后hòu事shì增zēng渲xuàn染rǎn:此cǐ史shǐ家jiā妙miào品pǐn也yě。如rú吕布bù取qǔ曹cáo豹bào之zhī女nǚ,本běn在zài未wèi夺duó徐xú州zhōu之zhī前qián,却què于yú困kùn下xià邳pī时shí叙xù之zhī;曹cáo操cāo望wàng梅méi止zhǐ渴kě,本běn在zài击jī张zhāng绣xiù之zhī日rì,却què于yú青qīng梅méi煮zhǔ酒时shí叙xù之zhī;管guǎn宁níng割gē席xí分fēn坐zuò,本běn在zài华huá歆xīn未wèi仕shì之zhī前qián,却què于yú破pò壁bì取qǔ后hòu时shí叙xù之zhī;吴wú夫fū人rén梦mèng月yuè,本běn在zài将jiāng生shēng孙sūn策cè之zhī前qián,却què于yú临lín终zhōng遗yí命mìng时shí叙xù之zhī;武wǔ侯hóu求黄huáng氏shì为wéi配pèi,本běn在zài未wèi出chū草cǎo庐lú之zhī前qián,却què于yú诸zhū葛gé瞻zhān死sǐ难nán时shí叙xù之zhī。诸zhū如rú此cǐ类lèi,亦yì指zhǐ不bù胜shèng屈qū。前qián能néng留步bù以yǐ应yīng后hòu,后hòu能néng回huí照zhào以yǐ应yīng前qián,令líng人rén读dú之zhī,真zhēn一yī篇piān如rú一yī句jù。

《三sān国guó》一yī书shū,有yǒu近jìn山shān浓nóng抹mǒ、远yuǎn树shù轻qīng描miáo之zhī妙miào。画huà家jiā之zhī法fǎ,于yú山shān与yǔ树shù之zhī近jìn者zhě,则zé浓nóng之zhī重zhòng之zhī;于yú山shān与yǔ树shù之zhī远yuǎn者zhě,则zé轻qīng之zhī淡dàn之zhī。不bù然rán,林lín麓lù迢tiáo遥yáo,峰fēng岚lán层céng叠dié,岂qǐ能néng于yú尺chǐ幅fú之zhī中zhōng,一yī一yī而ér详xiáng绘huì之zhī乎hū?作zuò文wén亦yì犹yóu是shì已yǐ。如rú皇huáng甫fǔ嵩sōng破pò黄huáng巾jīn,只zhī在zài朱zhū隽jùn一yī边biān打dǎ听tīng得dé来lái;袁yuán绍shào杀shā公gōng孙sūn瓒zàn,只zhī在zài曹cáo操cāo一yī边biān打dǎ听tīng得dé来lái;赵zhào云yún袭xí南nán郡jùn,关guān、张zhāng袭xí两liǎng郡jùn,只zhī在zài周zhōu郎láng眼yǎn中zhōng耳ěr中zhōng得dé来lái;昭zhāo烈liè杀shā杨yáng奉fèng、韩hán暹xiān,只zhī在zài昭zhāo烈liè口kǒu中zhōng叙xù来lái;张zhāng飞fēi夺duó古gǔ城chéng,在zài关guān公gōng耳ěr中zhōng听tīng来lái;简jiǎn雍yōng投tóu袁yuán绍shào,在zài昭zhāo烈liè口kǒu中zhōng说shuō来lái。至zhì若ruò曹cáo丕pī三sān路lù伐fá吴wú而ér皆jiē败bài,一yī路lù用yòng实shí写xiě,两liǎng路lù用yòng虚xū写xiě;武wǔ侯hóu退tuì曹cáo丕pī五wǔ路lù之zhī兵bīng,惟wéi遣qiǎn使shǐ入rù吴wú用yòng实shí写xiě,其qí四sì路lù皆jiē虚xū写xiě。诸zhū如rú此cǐ类lèi,又yòu指zhǐ不bù胜shèng屈qū。只zhī一yī句jù两liǎng句jù,正zhèng不bù知zhī包bāo却què几jī许xǔ事shì情qíng,省shěng却què几jī许xǔ笔bǐ墨mò。

《三sān国guó》一yī书shū,有yǒu奇qí峰fēng对duì插chā、锦jǐn屏píng对duì峙zhì之zhī妙miào。其qí对duì之zhī法fǎ,有yǒu正zhèng对duì者zhě,有yǒu反fǎn对duì者zhě,有yǒu一yī卷juàn之zhī中zhōng自zì为wéi对duì者zhě,有yǒu隔gé数shù十shí卷juàn而ér遥yáo为wéi对duì者zhě。如rú昭zhāo烈liè则zé自zì幼yòu便biàn大dà,曹cáo操cāo则zé自zì幼yòu便biàn奸jiān。张zhāng飞fēi则zé一yī味wèi性xìng急jí,何hé进jìn则zé一yī味wèi性xìng慢màn。议yì温wēn明míng是shì董dǒng卓zhuó无wú君jūn,杀shā丁dīng原yuán是shì吕布bù无wú父fù。袁yuán绍shào磐pán河hé之zhī战zhàn,胜shèng败bài无wú常cháng;孙sūn坚jiān岘xiàn山shān之zhī役yì,生shēng死sǐ不bù测cè。马mǎ腾téng勤qín王wáng室shì而ér无wú功gōng,不bù失shī为wéi忠zhōng;曹cáo操cāo报bào父fù雠chóu而ér不bù果guǒ,不bù得dé为wéi孝xiào。袁yuán绍shào起qǐ马mǎ步bù三sān军jūn而ér复fù回huí,是shì力lì可kě战zhàn而ér不bù断duàn;昭zhāo烈liè擒qín王wáng、刘二èr将jiāng而ér复fù纵zòng,是shì势shì不bù敌dí而ér从cóng权quán。孔kǒng融róng荐jiàn祢mí衡héng,是shì《缁zī衣yī》之zhī好hǎo;祢mí衡héng骂mà曹cáo操cāo,是shì《巷xiàng伯bó》之zhī心xīn。昭zhāo烈liè遇yù德dé操cāo,是shì无wú意yì相xiāng遭zāo;单dān福fú过guò新xīn野yě,是shì有yǒu心xīn来lái谒yè。曹cáo丕pī苦kǔ逼bī生shēng曹cáo植zhí,是shì同tóng气qì戈gē矛máo;昭zhāo烈liè痛tòng哭kū死sǐ关guān公gōng,是shì异yì姓xìng骨gǔ肉ròu。火huǒ熄xī上shàng方fāng谷gǔ,是shì司sī马mǎ之zhī数shù当dāng生shēng;灯dēng灭miè五wǔ丈zhàng原yuán,是shì诸zhū葛gé之zhī命mìng当dāng死sǐ。诸zhū如rú此cǐ类lèi,或huò正zhèng对duì,或huò反fǎn对duì,皆jiē一yī回huí之zhī中zhōng而ér自zì为wéi对duì者zhě也yě。如rú以yǐ国guó戚qī害hài国guó戚qī,则zé有yǒu何hé进jìn;以yǐ国guó戚qī荐jiàn国guó戚qī,则zé有yǒu伏fú完wán。李lǐ肃sù说shuō吕布bù,则zé以yǐ智zhì济jì其qí恶è;王wáng允yǔn说shuō吕布bù,则zé以yǐ巧qiǎo行háng其qí忠zhōng。张zhāng飞fēi失shī徐xú州zhōu,则zé以yǐ饮yǐn酒误wù事shì;吕布bù陷xiàn下xià邳pī,则zé以yǐ禁jīn酒受shòu殃yāng。关guān公gōng饮yǐn鲁lǔ肃sù之zhī酒,是shì一yī片piàn神shén威wēi;羊yáng祜hù饮yǐn陆lù抗kàng之zhī酒,是shì一yī团tuán和hé气qì。孔kǒng明míng不bù杀shā孟mèng获huò,是shì仁rén者zhě之zhī宽kuān;司sī马mǎ懿yì必bì杀shā公gōng孙sūn渊yuān,是shì奸jiān雄xióng之zhī刻kè。关guān公gōng义yì释shì曹cáo操cāo,是shì报bào其qí德dé于yú前qián;翼yì德dé义yì释shì严yán颜yán,是shì收shōu其qí用yòng于yú后hòu。武wǔ侯hóu不bù用yòng子zǐ午wǔ谷gǔ之zhī计jì,是shì慎shèn谋móu以yǐ图tú全quán;邓dèng艾ài不bù惧jù阴yīn平píng岭lǐng之zhī危wēi,是shì行háng险xiǎn以yǐ徼jiǎo幸xìng。曹cáo操cāo有yǒu病bìng,陈chén琳lín一yī骂mà便biàn好hǎo;王wáng郎láng无wú病bìng,孔kǒng明míng一yī骂mà便biàn亡wáng。孙sūn夫fū人rén好hǎo甲jiǎ兵bīng,是shì女nǚ中zhōng丈zhàng夫fū;司sī马mǎ懿yì受shòu巾jīn帼guó,是shì男nán中zhōng女nǚ子zǐ。八bā日rì而ér取qǔ上shàng庸yōng,则zé以yǐ速sù而ér神shén;百bǎi日rì而ér取qǔ襄xiāng平píng,则zé以yǐ迟chí而ér胜shèng。孔kǒng明míng屯tún田tián渭wèi滨bīn,是shì进jìn取qǔ主zhǔ谋móu,姜jiāng维wéi屯tún田tián沓tà中zhōng,是shì退tuì避bì之zhī计jì。曹cáo操cāo受shòu汉hàn之zhī九锡xī,是shì操cāo之zhī不bù臣chén;孙sūn权quán受shòu魏wèi之zhī九锡xī,是shì权quán之zhī不bù君jūn。曹cáo操cāo射shè鹿lù,义yì乖guāi于yú君jūn臣chén;曹cáo丕pī射shè鹿lù,情qíng动dòng于yú母mǔ子zǐ。杨yáng仪yí、魏wèi延yán,相xiāng争zhēng于yú班bān师shī之zhī日rì;邓dèng艾ài、钟zhōng会huì,相xiāng忌jì在zài用yòng兵bīng之zhī时shí。姜jiāng维wéi欲yù继jì孔kǒng明míng之zhī志zhì,人rén事shì逆nì乎hū天tiān心xīn;杜dù预yù能néng承chéng羊yáng祜hù之zhī谋móu,天tiān时shí应yīng乎hū人rén力lì。诸zhū如rú此cǐ类lèi,或huò正zhèng对duì,或huò反fǎn对duì,皆jiē不bù在zài一yī回huí之zhī中zhōng,而ér遥yáo相xiāng为wéi对duì者zhě也yě。诚chéng于yú此cǐ较jiào量liáng而ér比bǐ观guān焉yān,岂qǐ不bù足zú快kuài读dú古gǔ之zhī胸xiōng,而ér长cháng尚shàng论lùn之zhī识shí!

《三sān国guó》一yī书shū,有yǒu首shǒu尾wěi大dà照zhào应yīng、中zhōng间jiān大dà关guān锁suǒ处chǔ。如rú首shǒu回huí以yǐ十shí常cháng侍shì为wéi起qǐ,而ér末mò回huí有yǒu刘禅chán之zhī宠chǒng中zhōng贵guì以yǐ结jié之zhī,又yòu有yǒu孙sūn皓hào之zhī宠chǒng中zhōng贵guì以yǐ双shuāng结jié之zhī,此cǐ一yī大dà照zhào应yīng也yě。又yòu如rú首shǒu回huí以yǐ黄huáng巾jīn妖yāo术shù为wéi起qǐ,而ér末mò回huí有yǒu刘禅chán之zhī信xìn师shī婆pó以yǐ结jié之zhī,又yòu有yǒu孙sūn皓hào之zhī信xìn师shī婆pó以yǐ双shuāng结jié之zhī,此cǐ一yī大dà照zhào应yīng也yě。照zhào应yīng既jì在zài首shǒu尾wěi,而ér中zhōng间jiān百bǎi馀yú回huí之zhī内nèi若ruò无wú有yǒu与yǔ前qián后hòu相xiāng关guān合hé者zhě,则zé不bù成chéng章zhāng法fǎ矣yǐ。于yú是shì有yǒu伏fú完wán之zhī托tuō黄huáng门mén寄jì书shū、孙sūn亮liàng之zhī察chá黄huáng门mén盗dào蜜mì以yǐ关guān合hé前qián后hòu,又yòu有yǒu李lǐ傕què之zhī喜xǐ女nǚ巫wū、张zhāng鲁lǔ之zhī用yòng左zuǒ道dào以yǐ关guān合hé前qián后hòu。凡fán若ruò此cǐ者zhě,皆jiē天tiān造zào地dì设shè,以yǐ成chéng全quán篇piān之zhī结jié构gòu者zhě也yě。然rán犹yóu不bù止zhǐ此cǐ也yě,作zuò者zhě之zhī意yì,自zì宦huàn官guān、妖yāo术shù而ér外wài,尤yóu重zhòng在zài严yán诛zhū乱luàn臣chén贼zéi子zǐ,以yǐ自zì附fù于yú《春chūn秋qiū》之zhī义yì,故gù书shū中zhōng多duō录lù讨tǎo贼zéi之zhī忠zhōng,纪jì弑shì君jūn之zhī恶è。而ér首shǒu篇piān之zhī末mò,则zé终zhōng之zhī以yǐ张zhāng飞fēi之zhī勃bó然rán欲yù杀shā董dǒng卓zhuó;末mò篇piān之zhī末mò,则zé终zhōng之zhī以yǐ孙sūn皓hào之zhī隐yǐn然rán欲yù杀shā贾gǔ充chōng。由yóu此cǐ观guān之zhī,虽suī曰yuē演yǎn义yì,直zhí可kě继jì麟lín经jīng而ér无wú愧kuì耳ěr。

《三sān国guó》叙xù事shì之zhī佳jiā,直zhí与yǔ《史shǐ记jì》仿fǎng佛fó;而ér其qí叙xù事shì之zhī难nán,则zé有yǒu倍bèi难nán于yú《史shǐ记jì》者zhě。《史shǐ记jì》各gè国guó分fēn书shū,各gè人rén分fēn载zǎi,于yú是shì有yǒu本běn纪jì、世shì家jiā、列liè传chuán之zhī别bié。今jīn《三sān国guó》则zé不bù然rán,殆dài合hé本běn纪jì、世shì家jiā、列liè传chuán而ér总zǒng成chéng一yī篇piān。分fēn则zé文wén短duǎn而ér易yì工gōng,合hé则zé文wén长cháng而ér难nán好hǎo也yě。

读dú《三sān国guó》胜shèng读dú《列liè国guó志zhì》。夫fū《左zuǒ传chuán》、《国guó语yǔ》,诚chéng文wén章zhāng之zhī最zuì佳jiā者zhě,然rán左zuǒ氏shì依yī经jīng而ér立lì传chuán,经jīng既jì逐zhú段duàn各gè自zì成chéng文wén,传chuán亦yì逐zhú段duàn各gè自zì成chéng文wén,不bù相xiāng联lián属shǔ也yě。《国guó语yǔ》则zé离lí经jīng而ér自zì为wéi一yī书shū,可kě以yǐ联lián属shǔ矣yǐ,究竟jìng《周zhōu语yǔ》、《鲁lǔ语yǔ》、《晋jìn语yǔ》、《郑zhèng语yǔ》、《齐qí语yǔ》、《楚chǔ语yǔ》、《吴wú语yǔ》、《越yuè语yǔ》,八bā国guó分fēn作zuò八bā篇piān,亦yì不bù相xiāng联lián属shǔ也yě。后hòu人rén合hé《左zuǒ传chuán》、《国guó语yǔ》而ér为wéi《列liè国guó志zhì》,因yīn国guó多duō事shì烦fán,其qí段duàn落là处chǔ到dào底dǐ不bù能néng贯guàn串chuàn。今jīn《三sān国guó演yǎn义yì》,自zì首shǒu至zhì尾wěi读dú之zhī,无wú一yī处chǔ可kě断duàn,其qí书shū又yòu在zài《列liè国guó志zhì》之zhī上shàng。

读dú《三sān国guó》胜shèng读dú《西xī游yóu记jì》。《西xī游yóu》捏niē造zào妖yāo魔mó之zhī事shì,诞dàn而ér不bù经jīng,不bù若ruò《三sān国guó》实shí叙xù帝dì王wáng之zhī事shì,真zhēn而ér可kě考kǎo也yě。且qiě《西xī游yóu》好hǎo处chǔ,《三sān国guó》已yǐ皆jiē有yǒu之zhī。如rú哑yǎ泉quán、黑hēi泉quán之zhī类lèi,何hé异yì子zǐ母mǔ河hé、落là胎tāi泉quán之zhī奇qí。朵duǒ思sī大dà王wáng、木mù鹿lù大dà王wáng之zhī类lèi,何hé异yì牛niú魔mó、鹿lù力lì、金jīn角jiǎo、银yín角jiǎo之zhī号hào?伏fú波bō显xiǎn圣shèng,山shān神shén指zhǐ迷mí之zhī类lèi,何hé异yì南nán海hǎi观guān音yīn之zhī救jiù?只zhī一yī卷juàn汉hàn相xiāng南nán征zhēng记jì,便biàn抵dǐ得dé一yī部bù《西xī游yóu记jì》矣yǐ。至zhì于yú前qián而ér镇zhèn国guó寺sì,后hòu而ér玉yù泉quán山shān,或huò目mù视shì戒jiè刀dāo,脱tuō离lí火huǒ厄è,或huò望wàng空kōng一yī语yǔ,有yǒu同tóng棒bàng喝hē:岂qǐ必bì诵sòng「灵líng台tái方fāng寸cùn」、「斜xié月yuè三sān星xīng」之zhī文wén,乃nǎi悟wù禅chán心xīn乎hū哉zāi!

读dú《三sān国guó》胜shèng读dú《水shuǐ浒hǔ传chuán》。《水shuǐ浒hǔ》文wén字zì之zhī真zhēn,虽suī较jiào胜shèng《西xī游yóu》之zhī幻huàn,然rán无wú中zhōng生shēng有yǒu、任rèn意yì起qǐ灭miè,其qí匠jiàng心xīn不bù难nán,终zhōng不bù若ruò《三sān国guó》叙xù一yī定dìng之zhī事shì,无wú容róng改gǎi易yì而ér卒zú能néng匠jiàng心xīn之zhī为wéi难nán也yě。且qiě三sān国guó人rén才cái之zhī盛shèng,写xiě来lái各gè各gè出chū色sè,又yòu有yǒu高gāo出chū于yú吴wú用yòng、公gōng孙sūn胜shèng等děng万wàn万wàn者zhě。吾wú谓wèi「才cái子zǐ书shū」之zhī目mù,宜yí以yǐ《三sān国guó演yǎn义yì》为wéi第dì一yī。